All Rise, Now Please Leave: Buncrana Court hit by ongoing Legal Aid protest


Dozens of cases block-adjourned amid ongoing industrial action by local solicitors
Around fifty scheduled court hearings were postponed at Buncrana District Court this week as solicitors continued industrial action in opposition to proposed changes to the criminal Legal Aid system.
Only one criminal case proceeded before the court, involving a motoring offence, as the defendant was representing themselves and wished to have the matter dealt with on the day.
The remaining criminal matters were block-adjourned to future dates.
Family Law cases, the details of which are not reported, continued as normal, as they are unaffected by the ongoing action.
Addressing those present in court, Judge Emile Daly outlined the situation.
“The criminal matters won’t be proceeding due to the industrial action that is being undertaken by solicitors in this Court District in respect of Legal Aid matters,” Judge Daly said.
“I note that that’s the case and that those matters have been put back,” she added, as scores of people trundled out of the courtroom.
Members of the Donegal Bar Association have expanded their protest to what is effectively a full withdrawal of services, having initially withdrawn from emergency court sittings and from providing legal advice during Garda station interviews.
The action forms part of a nationwide campaign by criminal law practitioners, who are protesting proposed reforms to the criminal Legal Aid system being advanced by the Department of Justice.
Under the current system, solicitors appearing in the District Court are paid €239 for an accused person’s first appearance and €60 for each subsequent appearance. The proposed changes would replace that structure with a flat fee of €455 per client, regardless of how many court dates are required to conclude a case.
Concerns about the proposal have been widespread within the profession. A recent Law Society Gazette survey found that more than 200 solicitors believed the model was “neither fair nor workable”, while also warning that it could make it more difficult for defendants, particularly vulnerable people, to secure legal representation.
Practitioners have argued that this could ultimately lead to more delays across the already-clogged court system.
Earlier this year, the Law Society criticised the proposed scheme, stating: “Introducing one flat fee in criminal Legal Aid imposes an indeterminate amount of work while cutting the fees provided.”
The Donegal Bar Association has said that solicitors practising criminal law in the county stand united with their colleagues across the country in opposing both the proposed reforms and what they regard as the Department of Justice’s unilateral and provocative approach to their introduction.
