Judge ‘narrowly’ accepts jurisdiction in Greencastle case of assault causing harm


Gardai said the defendant made one reply after the charges were put to him, asking: “Are you going to charge him with anything?”
A Greencastle man charged with assault causing harm will have his case dealt with in the District Court after a judge said she was only “narrowly” prepared to accept jurisdiction following a review of the alleged injuries.
Brendan McCormick, of Crossroads, Greencastle, appeared before Carndonagh District Court sitting at Buncrana Courthouse on a number of charges, including assault causing harm contrary to Section 3 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act.
The charge relates to an alleged assault on Michael Doherty at Crossroads, Ballymacarthur, Greencastle, on June 4, 2025.
Outlining the case, Sgt Conor Mulkerns told the court that the Director of Public Prosecutions had directed that the assault causing harm matter could be dealt with summarily at District Court level.
Judge Emile Daly examined details of the case and was shown photographs of the alleged injuries sustained by the injured party. After reviewing the material, Judge Daly said she was “narrowly” agreeing to accept jurisdiction in the matter.
The decision means the charge will remain before the District Court rather than being sent forward to the Circuit Court, where more serious indictable offences are often dealt with.
Mr McCormick (57) also faces a separate assault charge alleging that he assaulted Michael Doherty in Greencastle on March 30, 2025, contrary to Section 2 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act.
In addition, he is charged with theft after it was alleged he stole a ladder valued at €200 belonging to Jason Aaron Smith on March 3, 2025. That charge is contrary to Section 4 of the Criminal Justice (Theft and Fraud Offences) Act 2001.
A further motoring misdemeanour charge alleges that McCormick failed to wear a seatbelt while driving through Main Street, Muff, in September 2025.
Garda Michael Connolly gave evidence of arrest, charge and caution. He told the court that Mr McCormick had been arrested at Buncrana Courthouse before being charged and cautioned.
Garda Connolly said the defendant made one reply after the charges were put to him, asking: “Are you going to charge him with anything?”
Gardaí raised no objection to bail. However, conditions were imposed requiring Mr McCormick to remain of good behaviour and to have absolutely no contact or communication with the injured party.
Addressing the court himself, Mr McCormick said he lived in the same small area and was concerned about the restrictions imposed on him because he was left with “no freedom to farm”.
Defence solicitor Frank Dorrian applied for disclosure of the evidence in all matters before the court. Legal Aid was also granted to the Buncrana solicitor.
Sgt Mulkerns said disclosure would be available by the end of July. Judge Daly remanded Mr McCormick on continuing bail and adjourned the case until September 15.
The judge warned Mr McCormick that it was “very important” that he abide by all the bail conditions, and she said his solicitor would explain that further to him.
