Developers fail to overturn rejected planning permission for Mountcharles flats

Overview of Mountcharlesplaceholder image
Overview of Mountcharles

An Coimisiún Pleanála upheld Donegal County Council's refused application for four apartments at derelict hall

Developers failed to overturn Donegal County Council’s decision to reject planning permission for four apartments at a derelict Mountcharles hall.

C&C Property Investment Ltd took an appeal to An Coimisiún Pleanála in April 2025 for the development of an apartment block consisting of four one-bed apartments over two storeys at the rear of Lower Main Street in Mountcharles.

Mountcharles Tidy Towns Committee and the Board of Management of St Peter’s National School, amongst others, wrote in third-party observations. 

It was written that there was an “informal agreement between the school and families attending that a one-way system is in pace with traffic leading from Main Street via the “School Lane”  and continuing to the Station Road for drop off and collection.” and that “many children walk to school using both access points from School Lane to Station Road.”

Mountcharles Tidy Towns Committee had previously written its opposition to the plans, which said: “As the village currently has over 19 vacant and/or derelict houses and sites, we would suggest that the local authority ensures that these dwellings and potential housing sites are developed in advance of the proposed scheme.”

In its appeal, C&C Property Investment Lyd acknowledged “the restrictive width of School Lane and the level of pedestrian and vehicular traffic associated with St Peter’s National School,” but felt these issues were “insufficient to warrant a refusal on traffic safety grounds.”

They said: “occupants would access the building via a footpath from the car park to a communal entrance at the rear of the building away from School Lane, and the safety of occupants is thereby protected, and the requirement for the footpath does not arise.”

In its Commission Order, An Coimisiún Pleanála rulted that the development was viewed to have “the potential to endanger public safety by reason of traffic hazard and obstruction to road users,” due to an access laneway, School Lane, which would serve the site area, is “severely restricted in width and provides for a direct shared pedestrian and vehicular link from the main street to the national school."

Emer Maughan, a Planning Commissioner of An Coimisiún Pleanála, added in her reasons and considerations for the failure of the application to be granted planning permission that the plans lacked “articulation and liveliness” and carried “no reference to the historical urban grain of the area.”

She said “the proposed development would militate against an attractive pedestrian environment” and would “compromise potential improvements to pedestrian and cycle links” to a nearby school.

Maughan concluded the development would “seriously injure the visual amenities of the area and the residential amenities of the proposed residents.” 

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice