Barrtalk: Milking it - Have we been wrong about milk all along?

Donegal Creameries 'full fat' milk is hard to beat for your cornflakes in the morning!placeholder image
Donegal Creameries 'full fat' milk is hard to beat for your cornflakes in the morning! | (Iconic)

Moville journalist Caoimhinn Barr writes a weekly column which has been running in the Inishowen Independent newspaper since 2010

I’m beginning to think I should stop listening to nutritional health advice altogether.

Not because I’m particularly unhealthy, but because I can’t keep up.

One minute we’re told something is bad for us. The next minute it’s good for us. Then it’s bad again. And, if you wait long enough, it will probably eventually be declared a ‘superfood’.

Eggs have been through this. Butter has been through it. Coffee has had its ups and downs. Red wine was once practically a medical prescription and is now viewed with considerably less enthusiasm.

And now, it seems, 'full-fat' milk is having something of a comeback.

A new Canadian study has added to growing evidence that full-fat dairy can be part of a healthy diet. Researchers at the University of Toronto followed 74 adults for 12 weeks and found that consuming three servings of full-fat dairy each day did not lead to weight gain, adverse changes in body composition nor increased cholesterol levels.

In fact, those eating more dairy showed improvements in blood pressure and consumed more calcium, protein and vitamin D.

For years, we were told that full-fat dairy was something to be approached with caution because of its saturated fat content. The sensible thing, apparently, was to reach for the low-fat milk while avoiding anything that actually tasted as though it had come from a cow.

I remember when skimmed milk became fashionable. It was essentially white water with a good public relations department.

Now researchers are suggesting that perhaps we shouldn’t judge a food purely by one ingredient. Dairy contains proteins, fats and other nutrients which interact with each other, something scientists rather neatly call the ‘Dairy Matrix’.

I’m old enough to remember going to see the movie [ironically, at the cinema in Derry too] back in the 1990s!

The interesting point is that the study found no adverse effects from three daily servings of full-fat dairy, despite all the saturated-fat concerns. That doesn’t mean we should suddenly start bathing in cream or eating blocks of butter for breakfast, but it does suggest that food is rather more complicated than the nutritional advice of previous decades sometimes made it sound.

And this is where I get confused.

For years, fat was the enemy. Then we discovered that some fats were actually good. Carbohydrates were next to find themselves in the dock. Then came the warnings about sugar. Salt has had its share of bad publicity.

Perhaps the real lesson is that we shouldn’t be quite so quick to declare foods either saints or sinners.

The Canadian researchers point out that dairy may be particularly useful for older people because it provides protein, calcium, vitamin D and energy in a relatively convenient package. So perhaps the humble glass of milk deserves another hearing.

Personally, I’m delighted. It means that all those years of being told to drink milk may not have been wasted after all.

Mind you, I’m taking nothing for granted. I’m going to enjoy my full-fat milk while I can.

Because judging by the history of nutritional advice, sometime around next month another scientist will announce that the safest thing to drink is apparently a glass of water – but only if it has been filtered through a quinoa smoothie.

At this stage, the only advice I’m prepared to swallow is the simplest: eat a variety of foods, don’t overdo any one thing – and try not to lose the plot over your cornflakes.

It seems that, when it comes to nutrition, we’re all still learning the ropes. And occasionally milking the wrong cow.

Anyway, I’m sticking with the tried and tested Donegal Creameries whole milk, which is the best anyway!

On the subject of which . . . I saw a guy parked in Centra Moville the other day necking a full litre of Donegal Creameries straight from the carton in his van – though that may be taking things too far! Everything in moderation.

The online gods are determined to bombard me with images of feet!placeholder image
The online gods are determined to bombard me with images of feet! | (Iconic)

Why is the internet so obsessed with fungal nail infections?

I have a question that has been troubling me lately: Why, exactly, does the internet think I have a particular interest in nail fungus?

I ask because every second page I open these days seems determined to introduce me to a toe that I would much rather never have met.

There they are, looming out from the screen: yellowing toenails, crusty-looking digits and all manner of horrible feet that apparently can be transformed into objects of beauty by applying some miracle gel or other.

I don’t know what I have done to deserve this.

I could be reading about local news, checking the weather or searching up the latest cricket results from the Hundred, when suddenly, bang, there’s a photograph of a toenail that looks like it has been excavated from an archaeological dig.

And it’s never just one ad. No, there’s a whole plethora of them. [They’re likely on this webpage now, if you’re reading online; but mercifully newspaper readers will be spared].

One ad promises to restore my toenails, another appears to offer some revolutionary fungal treatment and a third seems to suggest that the answer to all my foot-related problems is sitting in a tiny tube.

The really worrying thing is that I have never searched for nail fungus. Not once [Even though, full disclosure, I am prone to getting athlete’s foot at the swimming pool from time to time].

I have never typed 'fungal toenail treatment' into Google [except to search for an appropriate image for this column]. I have never clicked on a picture of a diseased toe. I have never even expressed an interest in feet beyond the basic requirement of having two of them, and sometimes looking at new Adidas or Jordan sneakers.

Why does the internet persist with bombarding me with images of deformed-looking feet then?

So, to the manufacturers of fungal nail gels, I have a simple request: leave my feet alone. If I ever develop an interest in your product, I promise I’ll Google it myself. Until then, I’d rather see advertisements for holidays, cars or even funeral plans. Anything, but another crusty foot pic [which I'll now inflict on readers instead!].

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice