Judge cries for victims' 'bravery' as Newtown man jailed for 11 years


Martin Joseph ‘Joe’ Cullen was jailed for historic sex offences spanning 14 years
A Newtowncunningham man was jailed for 11 years for historic sex offences at Letterkenny Circuit Court, in which Judge Roderick Maguire briefly broke down near the conclusion of the hearing when praising the “incredible bravery” of the victims.
Martin Joseph, known as ‘Joe’ Cullen, 64, who has an address in Colehill, Newtowncunningham, was present at Letterkenny Courthouse to hear his sentence for crimes involving sexual offences against young boys over a 14-year period.
Following the sentencing, a public spectator pointed at Cullen, describing him as “rotten” and said that he hoped he would be “haunted.”
Cullen was found guilty in July, following a five-day trial, of seven counts of sexual assault against five boys during a period between 1993 and 2007.
The charges that relate to Cullen were contrary to Section 2 of the Criminal Law (Rape) (Amendment) Act, 1990, as amended by Section 37 of the Sexual Offenders Act, 2001.
Cullen also pleaded guilty to a separate charge of child exploitation, contrary to Section 3(2) and 3(3) of the Child Trafficking and Pornography Act, 1998, relating to an offence dated between 2008 and 2010, against a young male, who was forced to watch Cullen masturbate.
At a previous hearing, victim impact statements were read, in which one person commented: “I am happy to see that this predator can not do this to anyone else, and the world is much safer with him locked up.”
Judge Maguire said: It was clear that there was a pattern of behaviour for at least 10 years. This is an aggravating factor.
“This was not a momentary single occasion.”
During the sentencing, Judge Maguire noted several victim impact statements, stating: “I have considered the impact statement. This assault has had a lifelong impact. He carries shame and embarrassment. It is right to say that there should be no shame or embarrassment, but this doesn’t take away any feelings.
Elsewhere, Judge Maguire referenced victim impact statements, which commented on how a victim suffered depression, felt anxious and afraid, and suffered psychologically.
He also detailed aggravating factors at various points during the sentencing, including age disparity, the “long and lasting effect” on victims, and that, in one assault, it “was planned that pornography was used as a prelude to an assault.”
Regarding mitigation, Judge Maguire said: “I have considered the fact that the perpetrator doesn’t have previous convictions, which has limited value.
“The crimes were not an aberration, but characteristic of this man.
“I note that there is no dependent child and there is no evidence before the court of the convicted man that would affect the sentence.”
Judge Maguire also noted the apology to the victims made by Cullen, but said it was of “limited value” as it didn’t “show insight” and “came late in the day.”
For the charges dating from 1993 to 2007, Judge Maguire announced headline sentences which ranged from nine-and-a-half years imprisonment to five years imprisonment, reduced to a range from eight-and-a-half years imprisonment to four-and-a-half-years imprisonment after mitigation.
Moving on to the separate charge of child exploitation, Judge Maguire noted “that this was incremental abuse of a further victim at a significant period of time after his previous offending,” and announced a headline sentence of nine years, reduced to seven years after mitigation.
Speaking on whether the charges should be served consecutively or concurrently, Judge Maguire said that consecutive charges should be used “sparingly,” but were “more appropriate when sexual offences affect more than one victim.”
Judge Maguire said there was “a huge betrayal of trust within a small community. The victims were all of an age where they could be embarrassed into silence.
“A recurring theme of the evidence was the gifts that were promised to the victims.
“The impact on all the victims has been significant.
“The predatory and repeated assaults in a small, close community need to be marked by an element of consecutive sentencing.
“I direct that the sentence for each victim should be served consecutively. I consider that the appropriate global figure is 11 years.”
He detailed several counts that were reduced from a mix of eight-and-a-half years, six years, and four-and-a-half years, to be reduced to two-and-a-half years, two years, and 18 months, to be served consecutively.
A pair of sentences, an eight-and-a-half-year jail term, and a four–and–a–half–year jail term were directed to be served in full, in concurrence with the consecutive charges.
Judge Maguire then reduced the seven-year sentence for child exploitation to 18 months to be served consecutively to the other counts, giving a total sentence of 11 years.
The sentence was backdated from when Cullen went into custody, at the conclusion of the first trial in 2025.
Speaking after sentencing, Judge Maguire appeared to briefly break down with emotion with a cracked voice.
He commented: “The impact on the victims of this predatory, abusive and manipulative man has been tragic and utterly devastating.
“They have dealt with this with incredible bravery.
“They are remarkable people who have suffered and will continue to suffer, but who are able to live their lives, and I know that they have the support of their loved ones and their families in the future.
“I hope that this will bring some measure of closure in their healing.”
