Man who was asleep behind the wheel of his jeep banned for being drunk-in-charge


“I explained to him that I believed he was drunk, and with the engine running, I suspected he was going to continue to drive”
A Buncrana man who was more than three times the limit when gardai found him asleep behind the wheel of his jeep on St Patrick’s Day last year has been banned from driving for three years.
John Doherty, of Sleadrin, Buncrana, denied being drunk-in-charge of a vehicle when he appeared before Buncrana District Court, insisting that he had pulled in because he was unwell and had no intention of driving home.
However, following a lengthy hearing, Judge Emile Daly found the 50-year-old guilty of intending to attempt to drive while under the influence, contrary to Section 5(4)(a) of the Road Traffic Act.
The judge imposed a mandatory three-year disqualification and fined him €300.
The court heard that Mr Doherty, who works in the building trade and has no previous convictions, was encountered by Garda Ray Hamilton at Applegreen service station in Burnfoot on Monday, March 17, 2025.
Garda Hamilton told the court he was dispatched to the scene at 3.56pm that afternoon following a report that a jeep had collided with a pole at the filling station and that a man had gotten out and become sick.
When he arrived, Garda Hamilton observed a grey Toyota Land Cruiser parked close to a pole at the rear of the premises. The vehicle’s lights were on, and the engine was running.
The Garda witness said he saw a man asleep in the driver’s seat with his head slumped forward and earbuds in his ears.
“He informed me that he had been coming from Derry, was on his way home, and had pulled in to sleep because he had had a few drinks the previous night,” Garda Hamilton told the court.
The garda said Mr Doherty also admitted that he had consumed a “few drinks” in Derry that day too.
Garda Hamilton said he immediately detected a strong smell of intoxicating liquor from the accused, whose eyes were glazed and face flushed. He said he believed Mr Doherty intended to continue his journey home had gardai not intervened, and he was arrested.
“I explained to him that I believed he was drunk, and with the engine running, I suspected he was going to continue to drive,” the garda said, adding that Mr Doherty was “very mannerly and compliant” following his arrest.
Mr Doherty was brought to Buncrana Garda Station, where an evidential breath test returned a reading of 75 microgrammes of alcohol per 100 millilitres of breath, which is three-and-a-half times the legal limit of 22 microgrammes.
During cross-examination, defence solicitor Kieran O’Gorman argued that his client had been parked on private property rather than in a public place. He produced a photograph of the location showing signage indicating it was private property.
However, Garda Hamilton said he regarded the area as part of the service station forecourt and noted that members of the public used it for parking and for accessing washing machines located there.
Mr O’Gorman also told the court that his client had pulled in because he suffered from stomach problems and had become ill, and that paramedics attended the scene. However, Garda Hamilton said he could not recall an ambulance being present.
The solicitor argued there was no evidence that Mr Doherty intended to drive home, saying his client planned to leave the vehicle overnight and arrange a lift instead.
“He was sound asleep, parked way off the road on private property,” Mr O’Gorman suggested.
Mr Doherty later gave evidence himself, telling the court he had stopped because he felt sick and had been vomiting.
He said he attempted to contact his wife and had put earbuds in so he would hear her call back.
He said he switched on the engine to keep warm and denied intending to drive.
“The next thing I knew, there was a guard at the window,” he said.
Mr Doherty also said he parked there because he knew the owner of the property and believed the jeep would be safe there overnight.
Under cross-examination by prosecuting Inspector Sean McDaid, Mr Doherty accepted he had been in Derry earlier but denied telling gardai he had consumed alcoholic drinks there.
Inspector McDaid put it to Mr Doherty: “You told the guard you were drinking in Derry, is that correct?”
“I told the guard I had a couple of drinks, but I didn’t say alcoholic drinks,” he replied.
Delivering her verdict, Judge Daly said she was satisfied by Garda Hamilton’s evidence that Mr Doherty had stated he was travelling home from Derry and that the engine of the vehicle was running when he was found.
“I’m satisfied based on the evidence of Garda Hamilton that the accused told him he was coming from Derry and that he was going home — and his engine was on,” the judge said.
Addressing the defence argument regarding private property, Judge Daly said she was satisfied the area where the jeep was parked was a place to which the public had access.
“The circumstances of this are clear. He drove from Derry, and from that it can be inferred that he had an intention to drive,” she said.
“Having had no qualms about driving from Derry, having had a few drinks, he intended to drive home to Buncrana.”
Judge Daly imposed a mandatory disqualification of three years. She also imposed a fine of €300.
Following the conviction, Mr O’Gorman said he did not agree with the verdict and asked the court to fix recognisance in the event of an appeal.
