It Occurs to Me: Haughey and Blaney: Friend or foe?

It Occurs to Me by Frank Galligan appears in the Donegal Democrat every Thursday


placeholder image
It Occurs to Me by Frank Galligan appears in the Donegal Democrat every Thursday | Iconic

‘Never one to let the hare sit, Vincent Browne has “done the State some service”’

There’s an old Greek proverb: “Better an honest enemy than a false friend."

I thought of that wise observation having just read 800 pages of Vincent Browne’s biography of Charlie Haughey, “Glory, Greed and Guns”. Bar the interminable (mostly boring) Dáil speeches, overall it’s an absolutely fascinating tome. I had heard Vincent on with Matt Cooper on Today FM a few weeks ago, and sadly, the once irascible growl had greatly weakened, yet it propelled me to get my hands on the book a few days later. As a Donegal man, I was particularly interested in his relationship with Neil Blaney, but more of that anon.

Browne begins by visiting a dying Haughey in Kinsealy and one can sense how torn he is between sympathising with his old protagonist and being the Vincent Browne we know - blunt and brutally direct. I was reminded of an interview I did some thirty years ago, where Tim Pat Coogan admitted that initially he was a Dev man (Irish Press Editor) but by the time he finished his research and published De Valera: Long Fellow: Long Shadow, he had become quite negative about the Long Fellow. Similarly with Browne, hard as he tried to empathise with Haughey - particularly towards the end - his decades of forensic research inclined him towards an equally negative overview. However, Browne’s final lines are telling:

“I shed tears on hearing of his death on the morning of 13 June 2006. He would have hated this book and probably would have regarded it as a betrayal. But he didn’t bear grudges for very long. I have tried to be fair, and he might have perceived that.” I had the pleasure of knowing the late great poet John Montague, whose first wife, Madeleine de Brauer, was descended from the Normandy aristocracy. Haughey was once in their company at a soiree and said to Montague: “Tell me, how does a boyo from the Clogher valley [in Co. Tyrone] manage to get his hands on a bird from Paris?” As Browne relates of the company: “There was a collective intake of breath…”. There were many more such intakes in his long, colourful and controversial life.

The first mention of Blaney comes after Sean Lemass’s resignation and the subsequent battle for Fianna Leader and Taoiseach: “There was no way that the party wanted a choice between Colley and Haughey, they were not going to have it. I knew from the different groups that came to me that the popular selection for Taoiseach at the time was Jack Lynch …… but at that time Lynch was not prepared to go … Haughey had asked Blaney for his backing but Blaney refused, saying “No, Charlie, you haven’t got the background”. Charlie did not forget that slight.

Kevin Boland had said that eventually, there came the point where there was nobody to challenge either Haughey or Colley, and with a Colley victory a real possibility, Boland decided that Blaney had to contest the election… and was confident Blaney could have counted on considerable support among rural deputies, while the support for Colley and Haughey, both Dublin deputies, was concentrated almost exclusively in the capital city… Boland firmly believed that ‘there would have been an overall victory for Blaney’.

As Browne observes: “Blaney was also a serious competitor and his nationalist credentials would have been significant assets, even in 1966. That may have weighed heavily with Haughey then and later.” According to Jack Lynch: “...a group of old backbenchers went to Lemass at this stage when Neil Blaney became a candidate. They were worried that the party would be damaged by division and dissension. They strongly pressed the case for getting me to stand as the sole contender.” Lynch won the day.

The ‘Troubles’ and The Arms Trial

Browne contends that “The Northern Ireland crisis of 1969 propelled” Haughey. “then aged 44, into a reckless intrigue, which could have led to his imprisonment for many years, his banishment from Fianna Fáil and the end of his ambition to become Taoiseach. That recklessness may have been prompted in part by his belief that Irish unity should be taken by force or via a deal with the British over the heads of Northern unionists, or alternatively, or perhaps in tandem, by an anxiety that Neil Blaney’s nationalist fundamentalism might trump his latent republicanism in a possible future Fianna Fáil leadership election.”

Intriguingly, Brown adds that although Lynch’s position as Taoiseach would have been bolstered by the 1969 electoral triumph, “...he remained diffident, almost subservient, to those ministers with ‘republican’ family credentials, notably Boland and Blaney. Lynch wanted to move Boland out of Local Government and return him to Social Welfare. Boland wouldn’t have it and ended up with both Local Government and Social Welfare. Lynch wanted to move Blaney from Agriculture to a new Ministry of Construction and Planning, but Blaney refused and remained in Agriculture.”

According to Kevin Rafter, who wrote “Neil Blaney, a Soldier of Destiny” in 1993, “...according to one reliable source, ‘he (Blaney) stormed into Lynch’s office and banged the table, until that was the end of that’. Lynch surrendered. Haughey must have watched and envied the Fanad man’s ability to dig his heels in. As regards the Troubles, Browne reminds us yet again that “The prospect of Neil Blaney’s openly republican leanings getting traction within Fianna Fáil impelled Haughey to rival his cabinet colleague in that arena, lest there be a Fianna Fáil leadership contest in the foreseeable future.”

Interestingly, Kevin Rafter writes: “A reliable Fine Gael source recalls ‘being confused by Blaney’s position at that time over the dominating role of the Unionists. In Donegal the plum positions went to Fianna Fáil people. And, without doubt, the plumest of the plum jobs went to Neil Blaney’s people. To my mind, Blaney was simply practising the same discriminatory thing as the Unionists over the Border”.

There may have been some merit in the ‘jobs’ allegations, but to compare it with what was happening in Derry and elsewhere is a huge quantum leap.

At the Ard Fheis after the sacking of both ministers by Jack Lynch, a leaflet was passed around the delegates which read: “Back Blaney. If you want a united Ireland in your lifetime, support Neil T. Blaney at this Ard Fheis. Events inside the North prove that the day is drawing nearer, Irish people are preparing for the final struggle against British rule in Ireland. The Seventies are the decade of victory in the national struggle.” If there was any ambiguity about Blaney’s Letterkenny speech a month previously, there could be none then. At that time Blaney was engaged in the plot to import arms, financed from the fund for the relief of distress in Northern Ireland. The line about ‘preparing for the final struggle against British rule in Ireland’ could have conveyed only that arrangements were underway to advance that ‘final struggle’.”

Vincent Browne, in his 1980 Magill series on the Arms Crisis, argued that responsibility for what happened ‘lies with Jack Lynch, not because of any deviousness or duplicity on his part, as some of his enemies would like to allege, rather because of an indecisiveness and weakness which was responsible for a great deal of the chaos that ensued’. When Blaney demanded:

“‘The Taoiseach should take the only honourable course and resign”, Rafter writes: "It took some cheek for Blaney to speak of honour, having lied about his own part in the attempted arms importation and his abandonment of his supposed friend, Albert Luykx (Belgium businessman with links to arms dealers), who had collaborated only at Blaney’s request. The Haughey-Blaney challenge to Lynch’s leadership dissolved a few days later on the tarmac at Dublin airport. Lynch returned to Dublin on 26 October (1970). He was met at the airport by all but two cabinet ministers, who were then out of the country on official business, and by 50 TDs and senators. Also at the airport, in a display of support, were members of the Fianna Fáil old guard: Frank Aiken, Seán MacEntee, Paddy Smith and Michael Hillery. The Haughey challenge died there and then.”

As regards the Arms Trial, Browne concludes: “The scale of Haughey’s and Blaney’s treachery in their role in the attempted illegal arms importation is astounding. Never previously in the history of the Irish state did any minister engage in such a flagrant defiance of the Constitution, the law and their obligations to the Taoiseach and their government colleagues. Nor has any minister behaved similarly since….The ease with which Haughey engaged in perjury after perjury reflected his shamelessness.”

One of the least enjoyable chapters in Browne’s book is simply called “Terry Keane”. I was reminded of one of John Montague’s poems, “Gossip”:

“Learn from the hare;

avoid too much notice,

crouch low, and quiet,

until the hunt passes.”

Never one to let the hare sit, Vincent Browne has “done the State some service”.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice