Roadworks company guilty plea following Inishowen family tragedy

John Mullan, 49, Amelia, 6 and Tomás, 14, died in the crash in August 2020placeholder image
John Mullan, 49, Amelia, 6 and Tomás, 14, died in the crash in August 2020 | The Mullan Hope Centre

Moville’s Geraldine Mullan gives moving and touching tribute to her husband and children who died in Lough Foyle accident

A roadworks company has pleaded guilty to two counts at Letterkenny Circuit Court following the deaths of a father and two children in a tragic road incident in Inishowen six years ago.

John Mullan, 49 and his children, Tomás, 14, and Amelia, 6, died after their car left the road, slid down an embankment at Quigley's Point and entered Lough Foyle on August 20, 2020.

Moville’s Geraldine Mullan managed to survive the accident and provided the court with a victim impact statement at Letterkenny Courthouse that made Judge Roderick Maguire give her his “deepest sympathy.”

Mrs Mullan, who was 45 at the time of the tragedy, was a front-seat passenger in the car being driven by her husband, John. She managed to survive after she had gotten out of the vehicle and stood on top of the car.

Declan Carr, who represented Whitemountain Quarries at the sitting, a company with an address in Newtownabbey, near Belfast, pleaded guilty to two counts.

He heard the charges that on or about August 20, 2020, at the R238, Greenbank Project, Three Trees, Quigley’s Point, there was a failing to discharge a duty as an employee to persons other than employees by failing to ensure, as far as reasonably practicable, that in the course of the works being carried out, individuals at the place of work were not exposed to a risk to their safety, health or welfare as provided, in Section 12 of the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005, contrary to Section 77(9)(a) of the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005.

That they failed to manage and conduct the guiding of public traffic through the said roadworks, thus being in breach of Section 12 of the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005, and as a consequence, John, Tomás and Amelia Mullan died, and Geraldine Mullan suffered personal injuries.

The prosecution’s case was outlined by Fiona Crawford BL, who confirmed the facts with Senior Inspector Brian McHugh of the Occupational Health Division, Health and Safety Authority.

The defence was represented by Ronan Kennedy SC.

Judge Maguire set a date for Friday, July 31, to finalise a sentence at the conclusion of the hearing on July 24.

During the hearing, dash-cam footage of a resident’s car that travelled on the same stretch of road, at a similar time of night that the Mullan family were travelling on, as they were returning home from a day trip in Derry, was shown.

Mr McHugh answered questions to the court regarding the events of the lead-up to the tragedy, including speaking about traffic management plans and communication, and the implementation of work on the road between the main contractors and subcontractors, before he answered questions from Mr Kennedy.

The court also heard that the night in question had seen adverse weather conditions, with the onset of Storm Ellen.

In a courtroom filled with close family and friends, the lone survivor of the tragedy and mother of the family, Geraldine Mullan, read a moving and impactful victim impact statement.

She described “the devastating and lifelong impact this tragedy has had” on her, and how she “continuously screamed” for her husband and children, but because they were in the water for so long, she knew they were no longer alive.

“The last sounds I heard from my children and my husband were their screams of terror,” said Mrs Mullan.

She paid tribute to the “brave firefighters, Gardaí and coastguards,” and to the paramedics who were “so kind and empathetic.”

“I remember the brave coastguard jumping into the water and holding on to me. I remember screaming that I wanted him to let go of me, but he told me he couldn’t.”

The court heard that following the tragedy, Mrs Mullan performed a “Sign of the Cross on their heads” and she “kissed them once more.”

Mrs Mullan said she suffered from constant flashbacks, as well as sustaining physical injuries during the accident, and was currently suffering from PTSD.

Speaking about her loss, she said: “It is difficult to put into words into how to cope from being in a family of four into a family of one. We were a strong, loving family.

“We were a close family unit, and our house was full with love, laughter, and happiness.

“My role and future plans were taken from me so abruptly as a result of the accident.”

Mrs Mullan took the opportunity to speak about her family individually. She described her husband, John, as her “rock,” “soulmate,” and “best friend.”

“I thought I had found my happily-ever-after, and I had, but I didn’t get to keep it.

“We built a life filled with memories alongside our children. He was my partner in every sense of the word.

“His loss has been deeply felt, not only by me, but by both of our families and our community.

“Each day brings the pain of waking up and remembering he is no longer here.

“I miss how he made my heart skip a beat. I don’t get to grow old with my best friend. I don’t get to experience normal family life. I feel like my life and my family were stolen from me.”

Continuing to her son, Tomás, Mrs Mullan said he was her “firstborn,” “a beautiful boy,” and “the light of my life.”

She stated: “He was perfect in every way.

“We formed an incredibly strong mother-and-son bond.

“Tomás’s pride and joy was being the best man at our wedding in 2012. He was a wonderful big brother to Amelia.

“I miss hearing his voice and his laugh. I miss his giggles that would brighten any day. He was caring and thoughtful, wise beyond his years, although he was 14.

“There was so much ahead for Tomás, so many milestones to come. His whole life was full of promise. I don’t get to celebrate his 18th birthday. I will never get to see him married and have children. I will never be a grandmother.

“The love of my firstborn is something that remains with me forever.

Commenting on her youngest child, Amelia, Mrs Mullan said: “She was truly the apple of her daddy’s eye and her big brother Tomás.

“She was full of life, despite her short six years. She was bubbly, mischievous, and always laughing.

“She loved her fashion and expressing her style. She enjoyed music and singing, playing Gaelic Football and was both a ‘Girly Girl’ and a ‘Tomboy.’

“She adored glitter and loved making videos, singing together and making TikToks.

“As with Tomás, I was and always will be endlessly proud of my beautiful daughter, Amelia.

“I won’t get to see her grow up, to marry, and to become the woman she was meant to be.

“There are no words that can truly express the way I have felt since the accident. Having to say goodbye and being unable to save them will stay with me forever.

“The silence in our home is overwhelming.

“A part of me was forever lost with them that night.”

Mrs Mullan told the court that she continued to avail of therapeutic support and felt blessed by the care and support of her family and friends. She said she had been dedicating her time to charitable causes, but struggles with the fact that her commute to work involves having to drive past the accident scene twice a day.

Regarding legal matters, she stated: “Not knowing whether the court case would happen has heightened my fears, anxiety and stress.”

Mrs Mullan told the court: “Everyday since the accident, I have lived with overwhelming sadness, loneliness and heartbreak.

“I have difficulties coping with everyday life.

“There are no words that can fully describe the pain of losing my immediate family in one moment.

“I continue to struggle with memories of that day.”

She finished her victim impact statement by saying: “I don’t want any other family to go through what I have gone through. I would not wish it on my worst enemy.”

Judge Maguire said he gave Mrs Mullan the “deepest sympathy of the court.”

Defence Barrister, Ronan Kennedy SC, offered his personal condolences to Mrs Mullan, and described her as “clearly a remarkable lady.”

Mr Kennedy said that a group of representatives from Whitemountain Quarries Ltd had attended the hearing to “demonstrate how serious Whitemountain takes this case” and that the “accident has caused a very long shadow over the company, a company that has always prided itself on safety.”

Mr Carr took the witness box to read a statement offering an apology to Mrs Mullan. He said: “As a father, son, brother, and husband, I can only try to imagine the depth of pain in your loss and to continue to express.”

He said: “No words can truly express the sorrow that a tragedy brings. I want to, on behalf of Whitemountain, express a sincere, unequivocal apology.

“We recognise in this instance, we didn’t meet the standards required. What happened should not have happened.

“We have reflected deeply on what has happened. We have been determined to learn from this.

“Where we have fallen short, we have sought to understand why, so it doesn’t happen again.

“Mrs Mullan, I know that nothing I can say today will change what you have lost. I am truly, truly sorry for your loss.”

Mr Kennedy told the court that as a mark of respect, Whitemountain operations had been stood down for the day of the court sitting.

He explained how the company had laid approximately 160km of road in Donegal from 2016 to 2020, and approximately 116km of road in Donegal from 2021 to 2026.

Mr Kennedy said the company had a “clear and unequivocal acceptance that they fell short by their own high standards.”

Judge Maguire intervened: “It was more than falling short of their own high standards in this instance.

“Are there particular steps in training in terms of health and safety?”

Mr Kennedy replied that various matters had been implemented since, and that Whitemountain were a company that received national and international awards for health and safety.

He explained to the court about various training programmes and campaigns since the accident took place, however, Judge Maguire said he wanted to know what in “specific terms,” from the incident in Quigley’s Point, the company had implemented changes on, so that it didn’t happen again, stating that it didn’t have to be a long documentation.

Mr Kennedy said he was “very happy to do that “ and that he had “boxes of material.” Mrs Crawford agreed that the prosecution was content to receive the documents before finalisation.

Before the close of the session, Mr Kennedy said: “If I can include, this case involves a very tragic loss of life with three people and an immeasurable loss and suffering for Mrs Mullan. These facts must be reflected in your sentence.

I would also point to the fact that there are a number of aggravating factors that we have identified no previous cases. This is a well-run organisation which takes its responsibilities seriously.

“No issues were identified pre-accident.

“It is not the case that there were previous near-misses being discharged or ignored. It certainly was not a case where there was a calculated decision to take any risk.

Mr Kennedy stated the company didn’t cut corners for profit or had failed to heed previous warnings.

He said: “This case really comes down to a decision that was taken onsite at a particular moment of time with the oncoming adverse weather, with the consequences that are absolutely unspeakable.

“I have heard that there is now a barrier in place. In circumstances where it appears that, that is the second accident on the particular stretch of road.

“I suggest that there is strong mitigation in the case.

“The remorse is genuine. There was an extremely high-level of cooperation. It has no previous convictions and has not come into adverse attention in the last six years.

“A plea of guilty in this case has one of significance.

“I am asking the court to be as lenient as it can.”

Judge Maguire set a date for the finalisation of the case to be on July 31.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice