Woman jailed for 'frenzied' killing of beloved Donegal mum in Glasgow


Claire Kilduff, inflicted a “frenzied” attack with a hammer and a knife on Ann Coll, a 61-year-old mother-of-three and grandmother-of-eight just before Christmas 2023
A woman has been jailed for a minimum of 21 years for the cold-blooded murder of a Donegal woman in her apartment in Scotland.
Claire Kilduff, inflicted a “frenzied” attack with a hammer and a knife on Ann Coll, a 61-year-old mother-of-three and grandmother-of-eight just before Christmas 2023.
The 40-year-old Kilduff was sentenced to life imprisonment by Lord Arthurson at the High Court in Glasgow. Kildruff must serve a minimum of 21 years behind bars before being eligible to apply for parole.
Kilduff tendered a plea to murdering Ms Coll just before she was due to stand trial.
Kilduff set upon Ms Coll, originally from Gweedore, with a hammer and a knife. Ms Coll was struck on the head, face and neck with a hammer while she was stabbed on the neck and body with a knife.
Kilduff reigned at least 21 blows with the hammer, causing extensive skull fracturing and repeatedly stabbed Ms Coll with the knife.
Such was the gravity of her injuries, police officers noted that brain matter was visible and protruding from one of her wounds.
A post mortem noted a total of seven stab wounds on Ms Coll’s body.
Kilduff hid the murder weapons as well as incriminating items of clothing in an underfloor cavity of her own home.
The attacker had searched on the internet for terms such as “deadliest stab wounds”, “stab wound to the neck” and “hammer to head injury”.
Kilduff had arrived at Ms Coll’s flat at 7.30pm and she knew the log-in details to her victim’s banking app.
Ms Coll was due to receive a payment of £400 the following day.
At 7.40pm her phone was disconnected from her home broadband network and a bank transfer of £320 from Ms Coll’s account to Kilduff’s was set up. At 12.51am on December 22, the money was transferred to Kilduff’s account.
Kilduff called 999 and claimed that she found Ms Coll in a pool of blood.
Ms Coll survived cancer twice and lived alone at Newfield Place, Rutherglen with her dog, Lola.
“Truly, as one of her children eloquently expressed matters, their lives will, due to the murder of their mother and grandmother by you that night, never be whole again,” Lord Arthurson said.
Lord Arthurson said he had to have regard to a plea of mitigation in which a senior counsel for Kilduff said she now took responsibility for the crime. The counsel asked the court to consider that she has health difficulties, had publicly expressed contrition and that this crime was out of keeping with her life to date.
Lord Arthurson described the attack as being a “frenzied and sustained episode of multi-instrumental violence upon a 61 year old lady in her own home”.
He said that Ms Coll suffered “catastrophic, extensive and horrifying” injuries.
He also noted the bank transfer into Kilduff’s account and the “highly incriminating internet searches” as well as the concealment of the weapon and clothing.
He said that these matters, together with the “fabricated content” of the 999 call and the lack of defensive injuries found at post mortem “are all highly suggestive of a cold blooded and intentional murder carried out for financial gain”.
He said the crime was completed when her “defenceless victim had no idea about the savage, merciless and wholly murderous attack” that was to be inflicted upon her.
The sentence was backdated to February 5, 2004 when Kilduff went into custody on these matters.
Police Scotland Detective Superintendent Lynsey Watters said: "This was a violent and shocking attack which has been devastating for Ann's family and friends.
"While no outcome can truly ease the pain of their loss, we hope this sentencing will bring some comfort to her loved ones as Kilduff faces the consequences of her actions.
"Violent incidents such as this are not tolerated in our communities and our officers will continue to work tirelessly to bring those responsible to justice."
