Mac’s View: McHugh tragedy: It’s like having a death in the family


The awful news of the death of James and Noreen McHugh has left me devastated. Words really can’t describe how I felt when I heard the news first about James on Monday evening and then of Noreen’s passing on Tuesday evening.
I’m just broken-hearted. James was such a fine man. I had a great friendship with him. He is the first player from the 1992 panel; we had also lost selector Seamus Bonar.
It is just terrible. I don’t know what to say. James had the heart of a lion. I can still remember him in Clones in the Ulster final nipping in before big Brian McGilligan and getting the ball.
No words can say what I feel and what I feel for the family as well. It is a terrible loss for them and for the Kilcar community.
I first encountered James when he was coming on to the Donegal minor panel in 1982 and my son Seanie was also on the panel.
Prior to that I had watched as his older brother, Martin, made a big breakthrough in the Donegal county final of 1980 and I brought him into the panel and then got to know the McHugh family. Martin and Michael Carr really dominated that 1980 county final.
James didn’t make the county panel but played U-21 and was very important for his club. Indeed, he was probably the best club player in the county around that time. When I came back in again in 1989 I brought him into the panel and within three years he had won two Ulster championship medals, an All-Ireland medal and an All-Star.
He was just an outstanding footballer. My abiding memory is that aforementioned incident in the Ulster final of 1992 when there was a ball out near the sideline, just in front of the dugouts and big Brian McGilligan was going for it. But James nipped in and whipped the ball and McGilligan travelled out. His display in the vital stages of that game was outstanding, especially as we were down to 14 men.
He gave a great individual display in what was a superb overall team performance that day.
And the one thing I have to say about James is that he was a very talented footballer and easy to work with. There was never a day’s difficulty with him. If you had to speak to him about a certain issue, it was never a problem.
He maintained that kind of personality all through his life, even after football. He was a very civil, down to earth, pleasant lad. That's the way he came across to me.
And then his wife, Noreen; they were a great couple. I wouldn’t have had as much contact with them in more recent times because Bundoran and Kilcar would have been in different divisions most years. I gather he was at the Ardara-Kilcar game on Sunday and he was an extremely loyal Kilcar man.


James was just one very good guy. That 1992 squad, they’re the boys; they’re my boys and they’ll always be my boys. He was the number 10 and he was so very, very talented.
And for such a small, slight guy, he was extremely brave. He was brave to the point, you could say he was dangerous. He would go for it.
And he was very creative at the same time with his use of the ball. He could take a score for the club or county and at club level he could play in any position.
To some people, he would have maybe lived in the shadow of Martin, but to me, he was just on the same level as Martin. Martin was an exceptionally talented player; probably one of the most talented I ever had.
James was different, he was a workaholic. He was a great worker. He could play anywhere.
During Covid I made contact with all of the squad and I had great chats with them including James. I would have phoned all of them as I still regard them as my boys.
They'll always be my boys. They were just a great set of lads. The last get-together we had was down in the Mount Errigal. We had a party and it turned out to be quite a party. I managed to be there at the finish and still playing the piano. I got them nearly all up to sing.
They were a great set; they're special and not just to myself but to the county as well. They were just like family to me and that’s why I’m so sad.
That squad held the imagination of the county until Jim McGuinness came along and won a second All-Ireland. But even then, the 1992 one was so special because it was the first.
He treasured that All-Ireland medal but I heard a little interview on Ocean FM on Tuesday where he was comparing the 1992 medal to the Donegal Senior Championship one he won the following year in 1993 when Kilcar shocked favourites and neighbours Killybegs. James said he couldn’t decide which was the more treasured.
That showed what a great clubman James McHugh was. He always wore his club on his sleeve and after his playing career made a big contribution as manager and mentor.
It has been an awful week with calls coming through from all of the 1992 squad, all devastated about the news. It’s going to be very difficult for them to line up as one of their own is taken home to their final resting place in Kilcar.
James carried himself so well. In recent years too he was an analyst on local radio on important games at club and county level and he was very articulate and knowledgeable about the game.
He was just a fine man; a fine boy when I encountered him first and he never changed.
Along with his brothers Martin and Enda, they gave an awful lot to Kilcar and Donegal.
James was just a brave football player and his workrate was phenomenal. And once he got the ball, it wasn’t going to be wasted. He had a particular style of getting away from trouble; he could wriggle free and he had great pace and drive.
He must have been very happy seeing his son Eoin being part of the present Donegal team and it kept the McHugh legacy alive. That Kilcar legacy goes back a long time and I remember some tough encounters on the old pitch in Towney.
It’s just a very sad week for Donegal and especially for the community of Kilcar. Our thoughts and prayers are with them and may God have mercy on their gentle souls.
Brian McEniff was in conversation with Peter Campbell