The Alternative View: Kerry trip - the good, the bad and the ugly

Donegal manager Jim McGuinness and Ryan McHugh following an incident at half-time  in Killarneyplaceholder image
Donegal manager Jim McGuinness and Ryan McHugh following an incident at half-time in Killarney | SPORTSFILE

In the Alternative View Peter Campbell reflects on a successful trip to Kerry that had some nasty connotations thrown in

What started as a journey of trepidation turned out to be one of the great moments for Donegal GAA supporters as they proudly supported their team in Fitzgerald Stadium, Killarney on Saturday.

In the week leading up to the game, if you believed the rumour mill then most of Donegal’s better players were injured and unlikely to be appearing. When the team lineouts were announced the supporters got a major boost and especially when No 26 Michael Langan was listed to start.

Afterwards they gathered outside the stadium to soak up the joy of winning and to hail their heroes as they emerged for the trip home after defeating Kerry in their own back yard. Kerry have lost just one championship game - that to Mayo a few years ago - in Killarney since 1975. That was the measure of Donegal’s win on Saturday.

The joy of winning, the amazing venue, a first half of football to live long in the memory - those were the good elements of the day and weekend.

The bad - unfortunately there were some leftovers from the recent National League final and a subsequent newspaper article by former Kerry great Darragh O’Shea probably didn’t help in this. The National League final fallout from Michael Murphy’s yellow card was always going to see Murphy and Donegal given a hostile reception.

O’Shea said in his column in the Irish Times that Kerry players should have taken their own retribution when the referee hadn’t dealt with Murphy in the League final. Even before the game started on Saturday it seemed as if the Kerry players were taking their cue from O’Shea as they targeted the Donegal man.

They were continually pointing out things to the officials if Murphy went anywhere near a Kerryman. And then in the second half when they knew the game was up a section of the Kerry support resorted to booing him every time he got the ball.

But it was like water off a duck’s back to the Glenswilly man, who ran the show from the middle of the field, then drove forward to fire over a point before being replaced and exiting to the dressing room a couple minutes before the end - again to a chorus of boos from sections of the Kerry support. I say sections because, like all counties, their supporters are not all like that, but they do have an element.

The ugly came in the moments before half-time. Firstly, Footballer of the Year David Clifford quite unnecessarily elbowed Caolan McGonagle to the head as a Donegal kick-out was being lined up. The incident went unpunished even though McGonagle was down and had to receive treatment. Some Donegal players, especially Gavin Mulreany, who was closest to it, were extremely annoyed.

And Clifford was involved again when McGonagle fielded a ball just as the hooter for half-time went. He came in with a shoulder along with corner-back Evan Looney. There wasn’t too much in this but it being the second hit by Clifford on McGonagle, the Donegal players surrounded him, which started a string of outbreaks of pushing and shoving.

But pushing and shoving is one thing, what happened to Ryan McHugh was just plain ugly. When you have a player the size of Diarmuid O’Connor holding you and another, Micheal Burns, comes in and opens your eye with an upper cut, then you have an offence that merits a very heavy sanction.

The subsequent intervention by Jim McGuinness in pointing the finger in the chest of Diarmuid O’Connor has dominated all the conversation around the incident. The analysis that McGuinness’s actions have to be dealt with in the same way as Dublin manager, Ger Brennan, for his involvement with a Galway mentor in a league game just doesn't stand up. They are like chalk and cheese.

And while all the talk has been about McGuinness, what is lost is the seriousness of the incident involving Burns, leaving a player with blood streaming down his face, and sneaking away from the scene like an innocent school boy. Even when shown the red card at the start of the second half, he threw out his hands as if to say, ‘what was that for?’ If the same incident happened on a public street outside the grounds, there could be a bigger penalty for Burns.

As it is the Kerryman will probably miss one championship game for the red card offence, while all the post-match talk was about suspending Jim McGuinness for the rest of the championship. GAA justice can be a strange animal at times. Thankfully, some common sense has prevailed with the news that no further action will be taken.

David Clifford is one of the greatest players we have witnessed in our lifetime playing the game of Gaelic football and you would pay to see him perform. On Saturday he was being marked by one of Donegal’s best ever markers, Brendan McCole, who does his job without resorting to anything nasty. Indeed, I’ve heard some say that the one thing he lacks is that element that maybe a Neil McGee had.

On Saturday, David Clifford, whether being frustrated or just following the general trend of the rest of his team in being physical, stepped over the line with his hit on McGonagle. The Kerry star is a big man and well able to look after himself but he doesn’t need to take cheap shots. In saying that, I would hope that when Kerry and Donegal meet again there will be no booing from Donegal supporters. It should just be a motivation for Donegal players to try and match the Kerryman, stride for stride.

BACK TO THE GOOD

The result of Saturday’s encounter will live long in the memory. The first half, even with some of the shenanigans, was top class with Gavin Mulreany making a goalline save in the opening seconds before Oisin Gallen sent Ciarán Moore through for a great opening goal.

Kerry responded but Donegal, with two pointers from Oisin Gallen, Ryan McHugh and Michael Langan, had the edge. The five point half-time lead; would it be enough? That wasn’t really the topic at the break; it was all about who would be sanctioned for the McHugh incident.

Referee Sean Hurson was probably a little lenient in the opening half and his officials missed the Clifford elbow. But when he called Micheal Burns to him and took out a red, the game was up for Kerry.

Indeed, if you were a Kerry supporter or a neutral, you would have been disappointed with the Kingdom in the second half. They hardly raised a gallop, needing Tony Brosnan to come off the bench to get their first score on 50 minutes.

Donegal were able to run their bench and stroll home, not something that was expected from the 5,000 or so supporters who made the trip.

With accommodation outrageously priced in Killarney, Donegal supporters found a place to stay in various locations in Kerry and in neighbouring counties. I ended up in Listowel on Friday and Saturday night and the locals were very welcoming, especially in John B Keane’s pub where Billy was in top form, even on Saturday night after the game.

There was a gang from Dungloe present and Billy was bemoaning the fact that Donegal had won despite scoring two offside goals! He also said that there was one thing that Donegal would not win in 2026 and Kerry would see to that. “Even if they send down Michael Murphy, they won’t win the Rose of Tralee this year,” quipped Keane.

One other note of praise before leaving Kerry was the facility that is Fitzgerald Stadium, Killarney. It is a magnificent venue and they know how to handle big events. The press facilities were just top class, akin to what you would experience in Croke Park. I know they have been at the top table almost all of their football life, but you would love to have that match day experience here in Donegal.

The journey home, taking the ferry from Tarbert to Killimer, was another highlight with the sun high in the sky on Sunday morning and the waters so calm.

Beating Kerry for a third time in four months is a new experience for Donegal and by all accounts a new experience for Kerry as well.

Last year Donegal had to play 10 games to reach the All-Ireland final. At the present rate, if they can keep winning, they can get back to the final by playing just five games.

Two down, three to go!

Match Facts

Kerry scorers: David Clifford 0-4,1f,1tp; Tony Brosnan 0-4, 2tp; 1f; Dylan Geaney 0-3; Paudie Clifford, Micheál Burns, Graham O’Sullivan, Tadhg Morley and Cillian Trant 0-1

Donegal scorers: Oisin Gallen 0-5,1tp; Ciaran Moore and Shea Malone 1-1; Michael Langan 0-5,1tp; Ryan McHugh 0-2,tp; Peadar Mogan 0-2; Max Campbell, Shane O’Donnell, Michael Murphy, Jason McGee 0-1 each.

Kerry: Shane Murphy; Evan Looney, Jason Foley, Dylan Casey; Tadhg Morley, Mike Breen, Graham O’Sullivan; Mark O’Shea, Diarmuid O’Connor; Micheál Burns, Kevin Evans, Sean O’Brien; Paudie Clifford, David Clifford, Dylan Geaney. Subs: Tony Brosnan for P Clifford (45), Brian Ó Beaglaoich for O’Sullivan (45), Joe O’Connor for Evans (48); Killian Spillane for Geaney (56); Cillian Trant for O’Brien (59)

Donegal: Gavin Mulreany; Eoghan Ban Gallagher, Brendan McCole, Max Campbell; Ryan McHugh, Caolan McGonagle, Finnbarr Roarty; Hugh McFadden, Jason McGee; Ciarán Moore, Michael Langan, Peadar Mogan; Conor O'Donnell, Michael Murphy, Oisin Gallen. Subs: Shane O’Donnell for McHugh (half-time); Shea Malone for Gallen (56), Ryan McHugh for Roarty (59), Daire Ó Baoill for Murphy (60), Turlough Carr for McFadden (63), Sean Martin for Campbell (64)

Referee: Sean Hurson (Tyrone)

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice