The Alternative View: Where did that Donegal performance come from?

Donegal's Caolan McGonagle rises to clear a Cork attack with Ryan McHugh in support  in Ballybofey on Saturday. Pic Thomas Gallagherplaceholder image
Donegal's Caolan McGonagle rises to clear a Cork attack with Ryan McHugh in support in Ballybofey on Saturday. Pic Thomas Gallagher | Donegal Democrat

In the Alternative View this week Peter Campbell reflects on a head-scratching display from Donegal who paid the penalty against Cork

For the second time at home this year Donegal failed to sparkle and now have to go the long road once more in the All-Ireland Championship.

Back at the end of April they failed to ignite against Down in O’Donnell Park, Letterkenny, but at least they hit 1-21 that day. On Saturday in the pristine new surface in MacCumhaill Park they could only manage 1-13, a paltry return that is not enough to win any game under the new rules.

The call for spectators to not invade the newly-laid pitch wasn’t a factor for the almost 100% Donegal support and who could blame the few Cork people who made the long journey in making their way on to congratulate their heroes. With the weather being kind on Saturday and the rain staying away they were hardly going to do any great damage to the surface anyway.

While the Cork supporters were celebrating, the Donegal supporters were left to ponder what was one of the poorest performances from a team under the guidance of Jim McGuinness. Indeed, he was the first to say so in the after-match interview and he was bemoaning the fact that Donegal have now lost their last three home championship matches - against Tyrone in MacCumhaill Park last year and now Down and Cork this year.

How could Donegal be so good in Killarney against Kerry and then be so poor last weekend against Cork.

It will be something that Jim McGuinness and his backroom team will need to sort before next weekend’s trip to the Capital to face Dublin. The one telling statistic from the game was that Cork hit six two pointers while Donegal failed to raise one orange flag. You could argue that half of those Cork orange flags could have been overturned if you had VAR, for stepping over the line and especially Tommy Walsh taking eight and seven steps respectively before firing a Hail Mary effort which landed just over the Donegal crossbar.

That would be looking for excuses and unfortunately for Donegal they weren’t good enough on Saturday. They got a few calls against them in the final quarter, that after the Cork players, mentors and stats men up at the back of the stand got Michael Murphy yellow carded, which also seemed to trigger the calls against Donegal in that vital final quarter.

But it all comes back to Donegal’s scoring stats - 1-13 was just not good enough. That will be the one area where a huge improvement will be needed for next weekend.

Donegal had a novel new tactic for the throw-in with Ryan McHugh going to midfield to be the man on the sideline with Michael Langan coming forward from centre-back to get any breaks. As it happened, Jason McGee won the throw-in but took a nasty fall on his back and there was a big worry for a short time that he might have done damage. Thankfully, he recovered and played his part.

Overall, it was a strange game with Cork very strong around the middle of the field and they were quite controlled when in possession, starving Donegal for long periods.

Still being five points up at half-time seemed a reasonable position and when Oisin Gallen increased that lead to seven by the 45th minute, it looked comfortable for the home side.

Three points in the final 25 minutes tells most of the Donegal story, the last of those coming with Turlough Carr firing for a goal with seconds left. The other two points came from a corner back Peadar Mogan and midfielder Jason McGee.

The momentum swung and Cork went for the jugular. They could have closed out the game but missed a few efforts to leave Donegal with a chance but they weren’t up for it.

The directness of Donegal towards the end of the National League seems to be missing. Conor O’Donnell, while doing well to be in position to finish off the Donegal goal, isn’t firing and it’s not for want of effort.

The bench didn’t provide the usual lift either and it was probably a big ask to bring in young Turlough Carr to act as a playmaker in that cauldron after getting his first couple of minutes in Killarney. The Four Masters teenager didn’t shirk responsibility and was unlucky to see his first effort come back off an upright. He will learn from Saturday’s experience and I’m quite confident that he will be back stronger because he has that in-built streak that is needed for county football.

At least Jim McGuinness was able to get to the Athletic Grounds in Armagh to see his son, Mark Anthony, help the Donegal minors to the Tier 2 All-Ireland title. There was plenty of pressure there also as Donegal were hanging on at the end against a very good Louth side, but at least it gives hope. This young Donegal minor side have had plenty of action this year and most of their games have gone down to the wire; hopefully that will stand to them in the years to come.

The defeat on Saturday means that Donegal are in the same boat as they were last year. They have to play an extra game to reach the quarter-final and in many ways they might be relieved that they have drawn Dublin and also that it is away from home.

The draw has pitted Kerry at home to Armagh and that will see one of the last two All-Ireland winners exit the stage next weekend. I imagine the likes of Galway and sitting back and really enjoying what has happened last weekend with a shocking series of results that were not foreseen.

Still, despite Donegal’s defeat and not being solely parochial, the championship has been one of the best we have seen for many’s a year. Donegal have been in Killarney and now going to Dublin while Monaghan have hardly had to employ a bus to get their team to games. The Athletic Grounds in Armagh for their Ulster semi-final with Derry. Apart from that they have played all their games in St Tiernach’s Park, Clones.

Westmeath have been the other story of the championship and but for a couple of bad mistakes by their ‘keeper on Sunday, they put up a good performance against Galway in Salthill, losing in the end by just three points. What a year it has been for Mark McHugh.

What odds would you have got on the four who have qualified for the quarter-finals through the front door - Louth, Tyrone, Galway and Cork - three of them plying their trade in Division 2 of the League last year.

I suppose if Donegal can resurrect their league form they would be happy to be in the draw opposite those four come Monday morning next on Morning Ireland on RTE 1. Apart from Galway, they would be happy enough to have a crack at Louth or Tyrone.

The small matter of getting over Dublin this weekend should be their main focus.

Match Stats

Donegal scorers: Oisin Gallen 0-4; Michael Murphy 0-2, 1f; Michael Langan 0-2; Ryan McHugh, Shane O’Donnell, Conor O’Donnell, Peadar Mogan, Jason McGee and Turlough Carr 0-1.

Cork scorers: Steven Sherlock 0-9, tp, 3tpf, 45; Luke Fahy (tp) and Tommy Walsh (tp) 0-2 each; Dara Sheedy, Seán McDonnell, Conor Corbett, Ian Maguire 0-1 each

Donegal: Shaun Patton; Eoghan Bán Gallagher, Brendan McCole, Peadar Mogan; Ryan McHugh, Caolan McGonagle, Finnbarr Roarty; Jason McGee, Hugh McFadden; Shane O’Donnell, Michael Langan, Ciarán Moore; Conor O’Donnell, Michael Murphy, Oisín Gallen. Subs: Caolan McColgan for McHugh (54), Daire O Baoill for S.O’Donnell (54), Turlough Carr for C.O’Donnell (60), Shea Malone for Gallen (65).

Cork: Patrick Doyle; Maurice Shanley, Daniel O’Mahony, Seán Meehan; Brian O’Driscoll, Tommy Walsh, Luke Fahy; Ian Maguire, Seán Walsh; Paul Walsh, Seán McDonnell, Dara Sheedy; Mark Cronin, Chris Óg Jones, Steven Sherlock.

Subs: Conor Corbett for Cronin (49), Jacob O’Driscoll for Meehan (60), Conor Cahalane for Walsh (65), Brian Hurley for Jones (65), Rory Maguire for Fahy (70).

Referee: David Gough (Meath).

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice