Makeshift Donegal will have taken plenty from Tyrone outing - Martin McHugh 

Michael Murphy in action against Tyrone and, inset, Martin McHughplaceholder image
Michael Murphy in action against Tyrone and, inset, Martin McHugh

Martin McHugh says Jim McGuinness did the prudent thing by giving those on the fringes the chance to impress in their loss to Tyrone and the 1992 legend says there are real pluses to take, even in defeat

Martin McHugh says makeshift Donegal will have learned plenty from their NFL loss to Tyrone in Letterkenny. 

In the end, Jim McGuinness’ side went down 0-19 to 0-25 in O’Donnell Park but 1992 legend McHugh feels Donegal’s approach to the fixture was spot on. 

Ever since their win over Derry in Ballyshannon - where the side moved onto absolute safety and eight league points - McGuinness made no secret that Donegal would need to begin to cut their cloth to suit. 

And that tailoring would completely centre in on their April 6 Ulster SFC preliminary round opener with the Oak Leafers in Ballybofey. 

McHugh has said he’d prefer to see the NFL Division 1 decider done away with completely and that the outright winners of the league lift the trophy. 

But from a commercial point of view, that’s a non-runner with the bean counters at Croke Park. So some breathing room in the calendar would instead need to be found if all sides are going to really embrace the latter rounds of the competition. 

“It was one of those games, from Donegal’s point of view,” McHugh told DonegalLive’s Conor Breslin on the GAA Podcast on Ocean FM.  

“They are safe in Division 1 and considering injuries and proximity to championship, they had to approach it a certain way. 

“I’ve said it before, there should be no league final. With it so tight to the start of the Ulster championship, it’s just not in any way practical. 

“There will be discussion around the team Donegal put out. But I think it’ll send a message to Croke Park that teams are just aiming to stay safe in the league. 

“And listen, the league is a great competition. But with the congested workload on the players right now, you are going to get a situation like Donegal’s. 

“They are going to use the last few rounds, knowing they are safe, to look at players and indeed protect some of the more established ones”. 

As regards to the weekend’s defeat to the Red Hands, McHugh explained that as well as those on the periphery looking to put hands up, there was also real benefit in getting minutes into some of the other established options. 

“To be quite honest, I think Donegal will have taken a lot out of the Tyrone game, even in defeat. 

“The management got a really good look at those on the fringes and I thought a few of them definitely stood up. 

“I think it only helps the panel and squad. The other big thing was that Michael Murphy got more good minutes under his belt. That’s great. 

“Odhran McFadden Ferry and Caolan McColgan, lads that would view themselves as going to be in that mix, also got runouts. 

“Jamie Brennan showed what he’s all about as well. So there are plenty of positives for Jim and his management to take away from Letterkenny”.  

Regardless of how next weekend plays out, and whether or not Donegal do or don’t make a league final, McHugh says the GAA will have taken notice of the predicament they currently find themselves in.

“The GAA will hopefully now look at it and admit that they have a problem here. Most teams don’t want to win the league. 

“The contrast in Galway going out to New York and last year’s National League champions coming to Ballybofey couldn’t be any wider. 

“And that’s no disrespect to New York. So it has to be looked at because it’s not a fair system. So you can’t criticise Donegal for whatever type of approach they take. 

“And listen, it’s not a hard fix. And if we want to persist with a league final all we need to do is find another few weeks breathing room in the calendar. Because, as I’ve said, it’s a great competition. I loved playing in it. 

“But that’s all we’re really talking about here a bit of breathing space. The back-to-back nature of what is ahead for Donegal if they made a league final and then moved on to championship, it’s too much. 

“These are still amateur footballers so you also have to be very conscious of that. But I expect change next year because of all of this”. 

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice