The Alternative View: Memories of glorious July Sundays in Clones rekindled last Saturday


Peter Campbell was in Celtic Park to enjoy one of the really great days for Donegal - first time they scored four goals in championship since 1974
Saturday evening heading for Celtic Park brought back memories of July Sundays in Clones at the end of the 1980s/early 1990s when Donegal were perennial visitors to St Tiernach’s Park.
It might have only been April, but the sun was high in the sky, the traffic was already backing up almost three hours before the 6.15 throw-in on the Donegal side of the Brandywell roundabout. The only difference was the tar was not melting.
And inside Celtic Park was thronged with the terraces packed so tight, as Pat Shortt might say, ‘you couldn’t turn a sweet in your mouth. That’s right’.
Unfortunately for the press corps, we were inside a glass furnace with no windows and the sun made it uncomfortable at times. It’s a pity that a few window openings were not included in the design which would have helped with the hot sun and also allowed us to listen to the great atmosphere outside. I was also concerned just before the throw-in when a number of Derry supporters had giant flags just in front of those windows and we wouldn’t see much. But thankfully, the flags were not an issue as the Donegal players on the pitch saw to that.
The Donegal supporters came in good numbers and when full, Celtic Park, is like a giant bowl of a stadium that has been dug out of the earth. The terrace banking is much steeper than most grounds and this creates a great atmosphere as everyone is close to the action.
Those Donegal supporters travelled in anticipation of something positive and most would have been happy with that, given the level of opposition, the injury list and the troubles of the last 12/15 months in Donegal GAA.
By the end of the game those supporters were walking around the Lone Moor Road with nothing but beaming smiles on their faces. It was in contrast to the Derry supporters who were leaving the ground early shocked at what they had witnessed.
We all travelled hoping for the best but we couldn’t foresee the ambush which Derry were subjected to by Jim McGuinness and his team. There was something surreal about it. The Derry goalkeeper, Odhran Lynch, took severe criticism for his part in the concession of four goals, but surely any blame has to be attached to the Derry management, who stubbornly refused to change their Plan A of pressing the Donegal kick-out with Lynch covering the space around midfield.
Looking on from the side the Donegal management team couldn’t believe their luck. They had obviously targeted the fact that Derry pressed high for the kick-out and that their ‘keeper was coming out to help at midfield.
With Shaun Patton’s kicking ability, it was an obvious ploy for Donegal to go over the top but they could not have known how spectacularly well it worked. Up against what was regarded as the best midfield in Ireland at the moment in Conor Glass and Brendan Rogers, Donegal just wiped them aside.
During the National League while Mickey Harte was keen to use his best team in every game, including playing Conor Glass a week after he won an All-Ireland club title with Glen, McGuinness was plotting to have a midfield partnership to match them. Jason McGee was given time to shake off an injury; Michael Langan was also eased into the action. April 20th was their date with destiny, and along with help from Ciaran Thompson and Caolan McGonagle, they dominated that important patch of grass between the two ‘45s’.
Make no doubt about it, that was the platform for Saturday’s win, but let me quickly add they had so many willing helpers, it made the game one to savour.
While the four players mentioned were central to the win, the one player who shone above all was Ryan McHugh, who gave a Murphyesque display. I hasten to say I think it was his best ever in a Donegal jersey. The break for 2023 has been a tonic. It was clear to see that injuries and concussions were affecting him. But he has returned and on Saturday he was just magic.
I watched the game on BBC and RTE on Saturday night, Sunday morning and apart from kick-starting Donegal into action, McHugh gave the ball away just once in a performance that was as close to perfection as you will find. He kicked two points, was involved in two of the goals and his passes from defence to set Donegal on the front foot in the second half were breathtaking. If you get the chance go back and watch the game again you will see a pass in the 73rd minute out of defence to Jamie Brennan that very few can play.
The Kilcar man turned 30 recently and he just knows the game well. He was the one who knew what was happening when the bizarre incident with ‘keeper Shaun Patton happened in the first half. And bizarre is the only way to describe it. This new rule, brought in a month ago where a player who receives treatment on the field must then leave the field and can only return from the half-way line and when there is a break in play, could have had a serious impact on the game.
At the time confusion reigned with Dáire Ó Baoill sent back to take the kick-out and he thought that Patton could come back on and take the kick. McHugh stepped in and you could see him urging Patton to sprint to the half-way line to shorten his time out of the action.
Thankfully, Caolan McGonagle won the throw-up and Donegal were able to retain possession and take the sting out of the situation. But it could have been disastrous.
I watched the Sunday Game on RTE on Sunday evening and I was expecting that the analysts would dissect the crazy situation, but there wasn’t a word about it.
The rule was brought in to stop teams feigning injury and winding down the clock, especially if they have a player black carded. But Saturday’s situation with Shaun Patton didn’t fit into either criteria. He was, as was subsequently proven, injured and there was no black card at the time.
It is clear that the rule, like many others, was not thought through. Surely it should not be applied the same to goalkeepers, who are maybe 130 yards from the half-way line. And if it is deemed necessary for the No 1 to have treatment off the field, then surely a temporary replacement should be allowed.
In relation to the rule being introduced to stop players feigning injury to eat into the 10 minute black card, why not make the black card punishment 10 minutes of playing time. Just a matter of stopping the watch if there is a stop in play. Common sense.
Then another question: Why was Mark Curran, who received treatment after a heavy hit in the final minutes, not asked to leave the field?
But bizarre incidents apart, let’s revel in the high number of top class performances by players in Donegal jerseys. Dáire Ó Baoill was lurking for the hat-trick when Jamie Brennan came thundering through to fire home the fourth goal. The Gaoth Dobhair man’s stock in embarrassing goalkeepers is rising fast and his general play was of a very high standard. Congrats to him on being named GAA.ie Player of the Week.
One of the other highlights of the Donegal display on Saturday night was the smooth and fast transition of the ball from back to front and in this regard apart from Ryan McHugh and Dáire Ó Baoill the displays of Ciaran Moore, Mark Curran, Peadar Mogan, Shane O’Donnell and Aaron Doherty were mesmerising at times, such was the slickness of the passes by hand and foot.
The return to the full-back position of Brendan McCole was timely as he again put the shackles on Shane McGuigan with the Slaughtneil man getting a couple of points when the game was over as a contest and Donegal happy to let Derry have the ball and keep out the goals.
It was just a good weekend all round. QPR winning 1-0 had Bundoran’s Noel Carr in dreamland as relegation can now be avoided. And he was also presented with Ard Comhairle tickets in Celtic Park!
One other statistic from the weekend was that it was the first time Donegal scored four goals in a championship match since they hit five against Antrim in 1974, with Seamus Bonar notching four of those - all of 50 years ago.
But now to back it up. We must go again with at least the same support as we take on Tyrone at the same venue this Sunday. This will be a much different game and I suggest that Tyrone will present a bigger problem. Derry were just not at the races last weekend. The Red Hand players will have to find great reserves of energy after going to extra-time to defeat Cavan, but they have a quality front line in Darren McCurry and the two Canavans.
And hats off to Matthew Donnelly to come back from a career-ending injury to play every second of that game at centre-half-back. Donnelly showed all his experience against Cavan but at 33 the Cavan game surely has taken something out of him. Still he showed on Sunday that there is not a better player around at winning a free.
McGuinness’s Donegal are no longer a secret, but they will also have got a good look at the new young Tyrone side. The run-out in Celtic Park for our younger players should stand to them and if they can bring the same energy as last week against Derry, then we can start planning for a trip to Clones on May 12th.
Tir Chonaill Abú.
Footnote: There was a little confusion at the end of the game as the scoreboard read 0-16 for Derry. They has not recorded the 14th point for the home side when Niall Toner scored. The operator may have lost interest with Donegal so far ahead.
Match Facts
Derry 0-17
Donegal 4-11
Derry scorers: Ethan Doherty, Shane McGuigan (2f) 0-4 each; Paul Cassidy (1m), Brendan Rogers 0-2 each; Chrissy McKaigue, Conor Doherty, Lachlan Murray, Gareth McKinless, Niall Toner 0-1 each
Donegal scorers: Daire Ó Baoill 2-1; Oisin Gallen (1-0pen, 3f) 1-3; Jamie Brennan 1-0; Ryan McHugh 0-2; Ciaran Moore, Peadar Mogan, Ciaran Thompson, Niall O'Donnell, Patrick McBrearty (f), 0-1 each.
Derry: Odhran Lynch; Conor McCluskey, Chrissy McKaigue, Diarmuid Baker; Conor Doherty, Eoin McEvoy, Padraig McGrogan; Conor Glass, Brendan Rogers; Ethan Doherty, Ciaran McFaul, Paul Cassidy; Niall Loughlin, Shane McGuigan, Lachlan Murray. Subs: Niall Toner for Loughlin (27), Gareth McKinless for McGrogan (28), Emmett Bradley for Murray (52), Donncha Gilmore for McKaigue (57), Eunan Mulholland for McFaul (66).
Donegal: Shaun Patton; Mark Curran, Ciaran Moore, Peadar Mogan; Ryan McHugh, Caolan McGonagle, Shane O'Donnell; Ciaran Thompson, Michael Langan; Brendan McCole, Niall O'Donnell, Daire O Baoill; Jason McGee, Oisin Gallen, Aaron Doherty. Subs: Gavin Mulreany for Patton (56), Jamie Brennan for Doherty (57), Patrick McBrearty for N.O'Donnell (58), Odhran Doherty for McGee (66), Kevin McGettigan for Curran (69).
Referee: David Gough (Meath).