The more things change the more they stay the same for Donegal icon Neil McGee

Neil McGee, second from left, Jim McGuinness, Luke Barrett and Colm McFaddenplaceholder image
Neil McGee, second from left, Jim McGuinness, Luke Barrett and Colm McFadden

A three-time All-Star, the 2012 All-Ireland winner explains that the winter months of 2024 weren’t any easier on Neil McGee ‘the coach’ than they ever were on Neil McGee ‘the player’

Neil McGee says the highs and lows of success and failure resonate just as hard as they ever did, even if his vantage point has changed in recent times.

A three-time All-Star, the 2012 All-Ireland winner explains that the winter months of 2024 weren’t any easier on Neil McGee ‘the coach’ than they ever were on Neil McGee ‘the player’.

The Gaoth Dobhair man, alongside Colm McFadden and Luke Barrett, now flank Jim McGuinness as he looks to steer Donegal back to the top of the provincial mountain and, hopefully, make an even bigger dent on the All-Ireland series later this season.

Watching the side put a disastrous 2023 firmly in the rearview mirror last May with an Ulster final penalty shootout win over Armagh, McGee explains that it hit just as sweetly as it ever did climbing the Clones steps in that famous No. 3 jersey.

Fast-forward to July and a narrow All-Ireland semi-final loss to Galway in Croke Park left Donegal players crestfallen as a real opportunity cruelly slipped from their grasp.

But the flip to the above sentiment is that McGee also says that disappointment cut just as deep as any previous loss suffered on Jones Road in a senior inter-county career that spanned an amazing 18 seasons.

“It’s still the same feeling, it was for me anyways,” he tells DonegalLive. “The highs are high but the lows are still low. At the end of the day you’re still there and giving so much, but in a much different type of way.

“You move on from being a player and of course you feel for the lads. You’re so happy when success comes like the Ulster title but you’re just as devastated when the thing falls short like the Galway game.

“You want the best for the lads and the supporters and it doesn’t matter if you’re playing or not. In the moment, the there and then, there isn’t much you can say.

“Words don’t really help in those situations. You have to stew and get over it in your own time. Everyone is different but it always takes me a little while.

“But once the thing gets close to starting back again, you move on. There is plenty of learning in that too, mulling it over and just finding some kind of end or conclusion”.

McGee says last season was very much a learning curve as he transitioned to his new role as part of that high-profile Donegal managerial team.

But with a spate of new playing rules dumped on Gaelic football in this season’s NFL, the ex-International Rules player would be forgiven for thinking or feeling like it was back to square one.

However, he explains that the traction of the group is much further down the line - and that the familiarity and experiences of last year has only galvanised things.

Yes, the new rules tipped into the mix by the Football Review Committee (FRC) has stirred things up as players and managers continue to get to grips with the consequences of all of that.

But McGee says it’s still a level playing field as Donegal prepare to get the defence of their provincial crown up and running on Sunday as Derry come to Ballybofey.

“It’s been good - there’s a good dynamic there,” he says on that experienced Donegal think-tank headed up by McGuinness.

“You’ve named a few there but even going outside of that there is a real team of people that do so much unseen work.

“The backroom team; there is no doubt about it that Jim is the manager and he is also the head coach. Atoin McFadden looks after S&S while Luke Barrett is very much hands on too like Jim with the coaching.

“Myself and Colm, it’s more like an individual thing in terms of chatting to players at both ends of the field and sometimes just observing.

“Having played for so long at that level, it’s the one thing that doesn’t leave you. So you try to look at at how players are maybe moving or fitting into that collective and just give advice if and when it’s needed.

“You have to be patient and you have to understand that everyone is looking to improve themselves. That’s very much the aim for players but it’s the same thing too for the likes of myself and Colm in what are very different roles now”.

In regards to the new playing rules, and if there is any scope left for surprises come championship, McGee says sides simply have to embrace them.

The NFL, even under the old playbook, always felt and looked like a much looser product with the shackles only ever really dusted off for championship.

But it’s very much a ‘wait and see’ response from McGee.placeholder image
But it’s very much a ‘wait and see’ response from McGee.

“It’s difficult to know just how the summer will open up. Kerry have been kicking the ball and finding form through the rules. But that’s Kerry football anyway.

“Sides are still getting bodies back so I think you have to be flexible; you have to know when to run the ball and when to kick it.

“From a coaching point of view, of course it has changed and it kind of is like a reset. So there is more scope now, with the new rules, where you do need to be able to hold your own as an individual.

“Those one-on-one situations are now presenting themselves and, again, it’s just a case of the lads learning to deal with that. If I can add to and speed up that process, then that’s brilliant.

“And it’s the exact same with Colm at the other end of the field. What he is able to pass on, listening to that, there is learning for everyone in those times, not just the attacking players”.

McGee admits that what remains difficult to get used to is the split season format that has squeezed up the inter-county calendar.

Walking out of Castlebar last weekend and appreciating that Donegal’s preliminary round tangle with the Oak Leafers was just a fortnight away is some departure from what he was used to as a player.

“That’s the big change, the turnaround is serious. There was always breathing space to be ready or to to be in contention. Now, a small piece of bad luck can have real consequences.

“You find your fitness throughout the season but I used to love that sort of four or five-week period where the build-up sort of slowly begins to tumbleweed.

“The weather improves, grass gets cut and then it’s summer time. But that’s probably just the old school in me!

“Every minute counts now. Times change and things move on. And like I said, players look after themselves so well now that it’s not really a fitness thing.

“These lads come back in January and are ready to go. But the build-up is just so quick now and it’s on you in a flash”.

Michael Murphy, the returning Donegal talisman, has certainly kept a low profile since that dramatic U-turn was first announced.

But his exploits on the field have spoken for themselves and it’s impossible to ignore just how good he’s looked in his appearances to date.

McGee says no one should be surprised that Murphy has had the impact he’s had but, at the same time, no one should underestimate either just how much work would have gone into getting back up to speed, on his own, and behind closed doors.placeholder image
McGee says no one should be surprised that Murphy has had the impact he’s had but, at the same time, no one should underestimate either just how much work would have gone into getting back up to speed, on his own, and behind closed doors.

“I know first hand the work Michael has done to get to the point of where he felt he was ready to step back up and step back in. He kept the head down and knuckled down something serious.

“He’s got himself into serious shape. And that wouldn’t have been two or three times a week. Michael is a different animal when it comes to that sort of thing.

“As well as the physical element to it, there is the diet and nutritional side to it as well. All of that would have been geared towards eventually reintegrating himself with the group.

“I remember hurting my back and being out for a certain period of time. At the age I was, chasing and looking to get back up to speed, it was an impossible task really.

“But what Michael has done, I have so much admiration for him. It doesn’t surprise me really when you think about the individual we’re talking about”.

Odhran McFadden Ferry did his fellow clubman dirty a few weeks back, disclosing McGee’s choice of music en route, around the back of Errigal, towards their training base in Convoy.

McGee affords himself a chuckle at that, explaining that those ‘joining the dots’ moments between training and the games, are crucial building blocks in cultivating the kind of environment that leads to success.

“It can be hot and heavy and you have to have your wits around you with these young lads,” he said. “They are all comedians now!

“But the banter is a big part of it. Everyone is there for the right reasons too and I have no doubt everyone is enjoying it.

“Whether it’s Joe McCloskey, the kitman, coming in and having a few laughs or whatever, you have to make the most of that time and just enjoy it.

“The hard work sort of looks after itself. But when the thing is fun, and you see people actually enjoying what they’re doing, that rubs off.

“There is no ego and no pecking order. Jim wouldn’t entertain that anyway.

“Younger people now, it’s funny, you think you’re plugged into what’s going on and in the blink of an eye everything changes.

“Even since I finished up playing, which doesn’t feel that long ago, things seem to have moved on completely. Some of it goes over my head and I just let it to be quite honest!”

Neil made a recent appearance on brother Eamon’s excellent episode of hit TG4 series Laochra Gael.

He says it will have given others a much better insight into the individual as the oldest McGee sibling candidly documented his past difficulties that have thankfully, and firmly, faded into the distance.

“I was sent an early link to it but I just waited until the night it aired. I liked it and I thought he did very well.

“I didn’t know what to expect. I sat in and obviously participated in it but you really have no idea how it’ll end up looking like.

“Kevin Cassidy did one before and I liked both of them. I think Eamon spoke really well. It gives others a small insight to Eamon as a person and not just as the Donegal footballer. It’s never straightforward”.

Finally, when pressed on whether or not there was a Laochra Gael episode in him…?

“No - definitely not! Sure, who’d be interested in that?!”

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice