Appeal fails against approved Donegal Donkey Sanctuary Visitor Centre

An Coimisíun Pleanála approves Donegal County Council's decision for Donegal Donkey Sanctuary Visitor's Centreplaceholder image
An Coimisíun Pleanála approves Donegal County Council's decision for Donegal Donkey Sanctuary Visitor's Centre | Donegal Donkey Sanctuary

An Coimisíun Pleanála upholds Donegal County Council decision to approve plans despite Inspector’s refusal recommendation

Donegal Donkey Sanctuary has overcome an appeal against Donegal County Council’s decision to grant planning permission to erect a visitor’s centre, after An Coimisíun Pleanála ruled in favour of Donegal County Council, and against the recommendation of its own planning inspector.

A decision by Donegal County Council to give approval for the application submitted by Sandra Parker of Donegal Donkey Sanctuary was made in April; however, an appeal against the approval was lodged to An Coimisíun Pleanála a few weeks later.

The approved plans were for the erection of a building to accommodate a visitor’s centre containing a café, a gift shop, classroom and storage, as well as the construction of a hay barn with adjoining paddocks and fencing, a storage shed and paddock with fencing, and connection to existing services and all associated site works at the premises of Donegal Donkey Sanctuary in Castledooey, Raphoe, between Manorcunningham and Lifford.

Donegal gave approval for planning permission for the proposals with 10 conditions.

An appeal was lodged by a company on behalf of their clients to An Coimisiún Pleanála, where it was set out that “a legal wayleave is required over our client’s site to remove the existing hedging, set back front boundary and maintain the visibility splays as specified on the Notification of Decision to Grant Planning Permission,” and that “until our clients legally provide the required visibility splays to the Donkey Sanctuary, the planning permission, if approved, cannot fully comply.

Furthermore, it was said: “The applicants for the proposed development have never approached our clients to date to discuss the visibility splays.”

Whilst the applicant made no response to the appeal, the Planning Authority chose to do so.

It was stated that conditions had been “imposed in order to alleviate any residential amenity concerns of any third-party properties,” and that “in terms of traffic safety, current development proposals will not impact on the approved revised entrance location to the facility.”

Moreover, it was commented that “it was previously established no third-party consent was required.”

The Planning Inspector, Ronan Murphy, in a report dated from July, recommended that planning permission be refused for the proposals.

He wrote: “Given the discrepancies and lack of detail submitted with the planning application and the appeal in respect to the proposals for the disposal and treatment of wastewater on site, the Coimisiún is not satisfied that effluent from the development can be satisfactorily treated and disposed of on site.

“The development would be prejudicial to public health and would, therefore, be contrary to proper planning and sustainable development of the area.”

Planning Commissioner for An Coimisíun Pleanála, Emer Maughan, provided her signature to grant approval for the Donegal Donkey Sanctuary’s proposals on August 5, with 15 conditions, going against Murphy’s recommendation.

It was viewed that “the proposed development would not seriously injure the residential amenities of the area, would not be prejudicial to public health and would not give rise to a traffic hazard.

“The proposed development would, therefore, be in accordance with the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.”

Consideration for the approval continued: as it was stated: “The Commission noted that the development proposed as part of the current application had been previously approved by Donegal County Council under Reg. Ref. 12/60142.

“In deciding not to accept the Inspector's sole reason for a recommendation to refuse permission in relation to the disposal and treatment of effluent on site, the Commission considered that the existing wastewater treatment plant on site was designed, installed and stated to be operating in line with the Site Assessment Report associated with the previous application (12/60142).

“The Commission considered that as there is no intensification of use arising from the proposed development over that which was previously permitted, it is satisfied that the disposal and treatment of wastewater can be satisfactorily treated and disposed of on site, subject to compliance with conditions below.”

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice