Search

16 Mar 2026

Donegal resident fails in appeal on extradition on charges of murder of RUC officer

John Edward McNicholl and Seamus Christopher O'Kane are wanted in the UK to face charges arising from an investigation into the INLA murder of Constable Robert John McPherson in Co Derry on July 26, 1975 and the attempted murder of a second constable

Donegal resident fails in appeal on extradition on charges of murder of RUC officer

The appeal was heard at the High Court in Dublin

Reporter:

Eoin Reynolds

16 Mar 2026 9:40 PM

Email:

news@donegallive.ie

The Court of Appeal has upheld a decision to extradite two men to Northern Ireland for offences related to the murder of an RUC officer 50 years ago, finding that fugitives who go on to live ordinary lives enjoy "no legitimate expectation of permanent immunity".
However, the three-judge court placed a stay on the extraditions to allow the men to ask the Supreme Court to hear their cases.
John Edward McNicholl (73) of Newmills, Letterkenny, and Seamus Christopher O'Kane (74) of Scalestown, Dunshaughlin, Co Meath are wanted in the UK. They face charges arising from an investigation into the INLA murder of 25-year-old Constable Robert John McPherson in Co Derry on July 26, 1975 and the attempted murder of a second constable.

Mr McNicholl is charged with murdering Constable McPherson and attempted murder while Mr O'Kane is charged with possession of firearms, including an RUC-issued firearm taken during the ambush on Constable McPherson. Those firearms were recovered in an RUC operation on February 16, 1976 at Garvagh, Co Derry.

Both men escaped from the Maze Prison in a dramatic tunnelling breakout in May 1976 before they could be put on trial. Mr O'Kane has been living openly in the Meath area for almost five decades while Mr McNicholl, who was deported from the United States, has been in the Republic since 2003.
  
At a previous sitting of the High court, Mr Justice Patrick McGrath said there was no evidence to suggest that Mr McNicholl and Mr O'Kane would not receive a fair trial in Northern Ireland, as he ruled that a delay in serving warrants on the men was not grounds for refusing their surrender.
Mr Justice Alex Owens at the Court of Appeal today (MON) said that while the long delays in seeking a warrant indicate "maladministration in Northern Ireland", he said the circumstances do not justify a refusal of the extradition request.
In his judgment, he wrote that the court does not have the power to dismiss an application for surrender just because the issuing State is unable to provide an explanation for not moving forward sooner. Lawyers for the two men had argued that the delay was evidence of an "abuse of process". However, Mr Justice Owens said delay alone, without evidence of a breach of a right under the Constitution or European Convention, is not a sufficient ground for refusal.
He further rejected suggestions that extradition would be a breach of the men's fundamental rights after they spent several decades living ordinary lives. As fugitives, the judge said, they enjoyed "no legitimate expectation of permanent immunity".
"By getting married, starting a family, buying a home or engaging in ordinary life," Mr Justice Owens said they did not diminish Ireland's interest in honouring its commitments under the Trade and Cooperation Agreement, which sets out the parameters for extradition to the UK.
Further arguments related to the men's health "are not the sort of exceptional matters which would justify a refusal," he said.

To continue reading this article,
please subscribe and support local journalism!

Subscribing will allow you access to all of our premium content and archived articles.

Subscribe

To continue reading this article for FREE,
please kindly register and/or log in.

Registration is absolutely 100% FREE and will help us personalise your experience on our sites. You can also sign up to our carefully curated newsletter(s) to keep up to date with your latest local news!

Register / Login

Most Popular

Sponsored Content

Multimedia

We've got Donegal Covered...

Subscribe or register today to discover more from DonegalLive.ie

Buy a paper

Buy the e-paper of the Donegal Democrat, Donegal People's Press, Donegal Post and Inish Times here for instant access to Donegal's premier news titles.

Buy Now
Get the news

Keep up with the latest news from Donegal with our daily newsletter featuring the most important stories of the day delivered to your inbox every evening at 5pm.

Register Here
Iconic Media is Ireland's largest independently owned regional newspaper and media group, with an unrivalled audience in print, online and mobile. We have 19 regional newspapers and 21 digital sites.

Iconic Digital Titles

  • Carlow Live
  • Clare Live
  • Derry Now
  • Donegal Live
  • Éire Bheo
  • Inish Live
  • Ireland Live
  • Kildare Live
  • Kildare Now
  • Kilkenny Live
  • Laois Live
  • Leitrim Live
  • Letterkenny Live
  • Limerick Live
  • Longford Live
  • Louth Live
  • Mayo Live
  • Nenagh Live
  • Offaly Live
  • Tipperary Live
  • Waterford Live

    • Iconic Print Titles

  • Clonmel Nationalist
  • County Derry Post
  • Derry News
  • Donegal Democrat
  • Donegal Post
  • Dundalk Democrat
  • Homes in Donegal
  • Inish Times
  • Kilkenny People
  • Leinster Express
  • Leinster Leader
  • Leitrim Observer
  • Letterkenny Live
  • Limerick Leader
  • Longford Leader
  • Mayo News
  • Midland Tribune
  • Tipperary Star
  • Tullamore Tribune

    • This publication supports the work of the Press Council of Ireland and Office of the Press Ombudsman, and our staff operate within the Code of Practice of the Press Council. You can obtain a copy of the Code, or contact the Council, at www.presscouncil.ie, Lo-call 1800 208 080 or email: info@presscouncil.ie.

    © 2026 Iconic Media