Woman crashed into local pub after suffering ‘some sort of lapse’

The woman (46) crashed into the wall of the Fisherman's Inn pub at Glengad in 2024.placeholder image
The woman (46) crashed into the wall of the Fisherman's Inn pub at Glengad in 2024. | Iconic

Defendant (46) convicted of careless driving and fined €400

A Glengad woman who crashed into a local pub after suffering “some sort of lapse” has avoided a driving ban after a court heard there was no evidence of dangerous driving on her part.

Denise McDaid, of Glentoskert, Culkeeny, Malin, appeared before Carndonagh District Court, sitting in Buncrana, charged with dangerous driving, which carries a mandatory disqualification period of at least two years.

However, following a defence submission, Judge Emile Daly agreed to reduce the charge against the 46-year-old mother-of-four to the lesser offence of careless driving on a guilty plea.

Defence solicitor Frank Dorrian argued there was no causative evidence of dangerous driving and said the circumstances pointed instead to an unexplained lapse on the part of his client.

He told the court that Ms McDaid sustained a head injury in the crash and had no recollection of the incident itself.

“She’s prepared to make a concession that something happened, but it wasn’t dangerous driving,” the solicitor said.

Gardai raised no objection in court to the charge being reduced.

Sergeant Conor Mulkerns outlined the facts of the case and told the court that gardai on mobile patrol received a report of a single-vehicle road traffic collision at Culkeeny, Malin, at 11.47pm on the night of Sunday, December 1, 2024.

When officers arrived at the scene, they found that a 2016 black Toyota Avensis had collided with the wall of the Fisherman’s Inn public house.

The court heard there was extensive damage to the entire front of the vehicle and that Ms McDaid had sustained serious injuries in the collision.

As part of the investigation, gardai obtained CCTV footage from nearby premises, Inishowen Frozen Foods.

The footage showed the Toyota travelling from the Malin direction towards Glengad before approaching a slight bend in the road.

However, instead of negotiating the bend, the vehicle continued straight ahead and travelled directly toward the Fisherman’s Inn before crashing into the wall of the premises.

The court heard there were no allegations of excessive speed and no evidence that alcohol or intoxication played any role in the incident.

Mr Dorrian stressed that point in his submissions to the court, saying there was no suggestion that his client had been driving improperly before the crash occurred.

“There’s no suggestion that she was doing anything improper or inappropriate in terms of driving this vehicle,” he said.

The solicitor explained that Ms McDaid had been returning home from her work at a local takeaway in Ballyliffin and was almost home when the collision happened.

He said she remained completely unable to explain why the incident occurred.

“She’s the mother of four children and grandmother of one, and sustained a significant head injury and is at a complete loss as to what happened,” Mr Dorrian told the court.

“Some sort of lapse caused this to happen, but she doesn’t know what happened.”

The solicitor added that his client had not driven at all since the incident because she was concerned that a similar episode could happen again.

“She can’t account for it; she’s completely puzzled by it, and hasn’t driven since out of concern that something like this might happen again,” he said.

Mr Dorrian told Judge Daly that although Ms McDaid hoped to drive again in the future, she had taken a cautious and responsible approach since the crash.

He urged the court not to impose a driving disqualification, saying his client wished to eventually return to driving when she felt safe and confident to do so.

The court also heard details of Ms McDaid’s financial circumstances, including that she earns approximately €280 per week.

In considering the matter, Judge Daly said she accepted the defence argument that the evidence did not support a conviction for dangerous driving.

The judge noted there was no evidence of excessive speed or any indication of reckless behaviour behind the wheel.

“Based on the facts outlined and no previous convictions, I will reduce the charge to careless driving,” Judge Daly said.

“There is evidence of a collision, but nothing can be implied in terms of dangerous driving from that.”

The judge further noted that Ms McDaid had no previous convictions and commended her for refraining from driving in the aftermath of the incident while she reflected on what had happened.

“I’m not going to disqualify her, given that she has no previous convictions,” Judge Daly said.

The judge also praised Ms McDaid for taking what she described as a cautious approach by staying off the road since the collision occurred.

Judge Daly ultimately recorded a conviction for careless driving and imposed a fine of €400, giving Ms McDaid six months in which to pay it.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice