Decision was made that caused a terrible tragedy says Donegal Coroner

Connor McGinley passed in tragic August 2023 single-vehicle collisionplaceholder image
Connor McGinley passed in tragic August 2023 single-vehicle collision

Coroner’s inquest occurred at Letterkenny courthouse into death of 19-year-old Milford man Connor McGinley in tragic vehicle collision in Kerrykeel

A practical joke involving a car following a night out in August 2023 was a “decision made that caused a terrible tragedy”, according to a Donegal coroner.

An inquest into the death of Connor McGinley, a 19-year-old man from Milford, returned a finding of accidental death by misadventure. Donegal coroner, Dr Denis McCauley, said that the “actions made the accident more likely to happen.”

Dr McCauley presided over the Coroner’s Court sitting at Letterkenny Courthouse on Wednesday, November 18, into the death of McGinley, who died in a single-vehicle collision in Kerrykeel in the early hours of August 5, 2023.

McGinley was the driver of a Nissan vehicle that belonged to a separate person within his friendship group, which collided with a pole on the roadside. A Senior Forensics Collision Investigator within Donegal estimated that the car was travelling at a speed of 113kph on impact.

In his deposition, Jaden de Reuck, the passenger of the vehicle in the incident in question, remembered how a group of friends, including himself and McGinley, had a night out in Rathmullan, before returning safely to McGinley’s residence in Milford, with no alcohol taken at the property.

De Reuck said he and McGinley then went outside of the property, to the car belonging to somebody else within the party, and met a friend who was smoking.

He continued: “He was in the back seat at this point. I know that the lights were on inside the car.

“It was then that Conor popped an idea. He was imitating the girls' reaction if we took the car for a spin. If they were ‘Oh my God! Where are the boys?’”

De Reuck said that McGinley started driving to Kerrykeel and that De Reuck took an eight-second Snapchat of the pair in the car also.

He added: “I remember the car going from side to side on the road. I don’t remember how far it took to Kerrykeel.

“I don’t know how fast we were going, but we should not have been going as fast as we were.

“I remember stepping out of (the) car and realised I was missing my right shoe. I then turned round and saw Connor.”

Detective Sergeant Garda Gráinne McLoone of Ballyshannon Garda Station recalled to the Coroner that it was “a very wet and dark day,” with the surface being “very wet” and “observed a red Nissan car on the side of the road.”

Garda Suzanne Gordon of Milford Garda Station said that CCTV from the neighbouring property showed two males leaving the property in the vehicle.

She said: “Dash-cam footage shows the car travelling out of the driveway, travelling to Kerrykeel, before turning back in the direction of Milford.

“Two voices could be heard.

“Jaden could be heard telling Connor to slow down.

“The dash-cam cuts out following the collision.”

Dr McCauley said: “Connor thought it would be funny to take the car for a spin.

“Connor free-wheeled the car out of the driveway so the girls could not hear the car.”

He noted that the Snapchat was sent by De Reuck at 3.19am.

Evidence was given that an ambulance was dispatched at 3.36am.

Regarding the post-mortem, Dr McCauley said: “Connor’s major injury was a traumatic brain injury, but he also had a chest and abdominal injury.

“It was mentioned that there was some alcohol in his system, but it was at a level in his blood of 227.”

The drink-drive limit in Ireland is 50 mg per 100 ml of blood for fully licenced drivers, and 20 mg per 100 ml of blood for learner, novice, and professional drivers.

Garda Gerard McCauley, a Senior Forensics Collision Investigator, said that there was no fault with the car itself, and the “road surface was wet, but the weather did not contribute to the collision.”

He noted that the road in question, the R246 from Kerrykeel to Milford, was covered by an 80 kph speed limit, but estimated that the vehicle’s speed was 113 kph on impact.

The car, according to Gda McCauley, rotated in an anti-clockwise direction, with the area of impact on a bank, before the driver’s side of the vehicle impacted a telegraph pole.

When asked how the car lost control, Gda McCauley replied: “It is not a sharp bend. It is quite a long, easy bend.

“He was going a bit too fast when he came out of the corner.

“If he were driving at the speed limit, the wetness would not have been a factor.

“It was horrific bad luck in where the impact point was.”

In recording McGinley’s passing as an accidental death by misadventure, Dr McCauley said he had died as a result of a road traffic collision that was an accident, but that his “actions made the accident more likely to happen.”

“I just give my condolences, said Dr McCauley. “It is such a terrible accident. It is one of those things that they did everything right, and then a decision was made that caused a terrible tragedy.”

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice