Ward warns scheme may exclude severely damaged homes on chemical ‘snapshot’ tests

Redress Party TD Charles Ward has identified more flaws in the redress scheme.placeholder image
Redress Party TD Charles Ward has identified more flaws in the redress scheme. | (Iconic)

Research suggests that present-day chemical readings may not accurately reflect the original cause of failure once the system has chemically evolved

Donegal Deputy Charles Ward has told the Dáil that Ireland’s defective concrete block scheme may be excluding structurally failing homes due to a reliance on present-day sulphur readings that do not reflect the full history of chemical deterioration.

Raising the issue directly with the Taoiseach, the 100% Redress Party leader cited engineering reports on homes classified as Group 4 – the highest level of structural damage – where widespread cracking, displacement at openings, moisture ingress, and breakdown of the concrete fabric were recorded.

The same reports also identify clear chemical deterioration, including sulphate attack, gypsum replacing cement binder, secondary ettringite formation, mobile sulphates within the concrete, and full carbonation of the cement matrix.

Despite these findings, the homes were excluded from remediation on the basis of low present-day sulphide levels and limited visible pyrrhotite, with engineers concluding that sulphates were likely externally sourced rather than originating within the defective blocks.

Ward challenged this approach, arguing that it relies too heavily on a “snapshot” of remaining sulphur rather than the full evolution of the damage process.

He pointed to 2026 research by Leemann, Münch and Dunlop, which indicates Internal Sulphate Attack can progress even where sulphide levels appear low, as sulphides are consumed, transformed into secondary minerals, or redistributed during long-term deterioration.

The research suggests that present-day chemical readings may not accurately reflect the original cause of failure once the system has chemically evolved.

Using a fire analogy, Ward said it would be incorrect to conclude there was no fire simply because the flames have gone and only structural damage remains.

He questioned whether determinations under I.S. 465 should be left primarily to engineering interpretation and threshold testing, or whether independent materials science expertise should play a central role in assessing how these complex chemical processes develop over time.

Deputy Ward warns that the current approach risks excluding homes showing advanced failure on the basis of incomplete chemical evidence, rather than the full scientific picture of deterioration.

The issue is expected to intensify political scrutiny of how I.S. 465:2026 is being applied, particularly in borderline cases where chemical signatures have evolved beyond clear attribution to original defective materials.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice