‘My life is now to survive for my children’: Joanne’s heartbreaking plea for safer roads

Joanne McLaughlin and son Tiarnan at Leinster House for the launch of the Oireachtas road safety report. Inset: Natalie and Ella McLaughlin.placeholder image
Joanne McLaughlin and son Tiarnan at Leinster House for the launch of the Oireachtas road safety report. Inset: Natalie and Ella McLaughlin. | Iconic

Joanne McLaughlin speaks of family's devastation as she attends launch of major Oireachtas road safety report at Leinster House

An Inishowen grandmother who lost her daughter and six-year-old granddaughter in a road traffic collision last year has called for more gardaí on local roads and tougher penalties for dangerous drivers, saying education alone is not enough to change behaviour.

Joanne McLaughlin from Carndonagh was speaking at Leinster House on Thursday, where she attended the launch of a major report by the Oireachtas Transport Committee on road safety, alongside her son Tiarnan and representatives of other families who have lost loved ones on Irish roads.

Her daughter Natalie, who would have turned 29 today, and six-year-old granddaughter Ella McLaughlin died following a road traffic collision at Carrowmore, Glentogher, close to Carndonagh, on July 2, 2025.

Natalie's partner, Tyrone, and her younger daughter, Rhea-Rose, who was just 18 months old at the time, were also seriously injured.

A 19-year-old man, Lochlainn Doherty, from Clonmany, has been charged with eight offences in connection with the fatal collision.

The charges include two counts of dangerous driving causing the deaths of Natalie and Ella McLaughlin, and two counts of dangerous driving causing serious bodily harm to Tyrone Irwin and Rhea Irwin.

He is also charged with two counts of driving without insurance and two counts of driving without a driving licence. The charges relate to incidents at the Isle of Doagh and Glentogher, Carndonagh.

Speaking to the Transport Committee about the impact of the tragedy, Joanne said her family had been left devastated by the loss.

"Our family was destroyed; we are destroyed as a family, it's complete devastation throughout the family.

"My life now is to survive for my children, that's the reality of what we're talking about today."

Joanne said she wanted to see a significant increase in the number of gardaí patrolling Donegal's roads, arguing that stronger enforcement and deterrence were needed to prevent further tragedies.

“In Donegal, we need more guards. Education is great for the young people because there's a big culture in cars, speeding, all that skids and all they do; it's not about education, it's about deterrence, they need guards, they need punishment, they need to know that whenever they do something, it's wrong."

An emotional Joanne also called for the Government to implement tougher sentences for those convicted of serious road traffic offences, saying existing penalties were not enough to deter dangerous driving.

"They need to increase the sentencing, so that people have a deterrence, they're just laughing, that's what they're doing. The young people are just laughing. They need to know that there's deterrence, that they're going to get in trouble, that they can't drive, that they're going to be put off the road for life or for as long as they can."

The Inishowen grandmother also noted that the lack of public transport in Donegal meant people were heavily dependent on cars, but stressed that this made road safety enforcement all the more important.

"Where we are, there's not a good public transport system, there are no trains, everybody has to drive, and this is what they do, they're rallying all around the road, and they don't care."

She questioned whether road safety education sessions were having the desired impact on some young drivers, saying that some were not taking the message seriously.

The family's loss was among the experiences highlighted at the launch of the Oireachtas Transport Committee's report, which contains 52 recommendations aimed at tackling the rising number of deaths and serious injuries on Irish roads.

Committee chairman, Fine Gael TD Michael Murphy, said the need for action had become increasingly urgent following 190 road deaths in 2025, the highest annual total in more than a decade.

He said 162 people had lost their lives on Irish roads so far this year.

Speaking at the launch, Deputy Murphy said: "We have a crisis."

He added that "these statistics represent far more than numbers. Behind every fatality is a family enduring unimaginable loss and behind every serious injury are lives and futures that may be permanently altered."

The committee's report calls for the establishment of an independent Road Safety Commissioner, with responsibility for coordinating road safety measures across Government departments, State agencies and local authorities.

The report also calls for the number of roads policing gardaí to be restored to 2009 levels. There are currently approximately 660 traffic gardaí, compared with more than 1,000 in 2009.

Among its other recommendations is increasing the maximum prison sentence for dangerous driving causing death or serious bodily injury from 10 to 14 years.

The committee also wants driving disqualification periods to begin after an offender is released from prison, rather than running concurrently with their custodial sentence.

It has called for additional safety cameras to be deployed without delay, a default 30km/h speed limit in built-up areas and a new graduated penalty point system reflecting the seriousness of driving offences. This is despite the Government proposing this previously in 2024 and not following through on it.

Other proposals include introducing motorway and rural road driving experience as part of essential driver training and examining tougher penalties for drivers who deliberately travel the wrong way down a motorway.

The committee also wants legislation recognising the loss of a pregnancy resulting from careless or dangerous driving to be progressed.

The report follows hearings with road safety campaigners, An Garda Síochána, the Road Safety Authority and other organisations.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice