Donegal were the better team - Martin Carney


Former Ulster winner with Donegal Martin Carney felt that Donegal were better than Mayo but he also felt sorry that Mayo did not get the draw that would have seen them through
Former Donegal player Martin Carney really enjoyed the fare on offer in King & Moffatt Dr Hyde Park, Roscommon on Sunday but he also felt that Donegal were marginally the better team on the day.
Donegal overcame Mayo in the final group game in the All-Ireland Group 1 series with Ciaran Moore’s late winner dumping Mayo out of the championship for 2025.
With 15 seconds left on the clock, Mayo got back level and a draw would have secured third place and a preliminary quarter-final tie but Moore won the kick-out as the hooter sounded and he sprinted forward to bury the Mayo hopes with the winning score.
“It was a fabulous second half. But to be honest with you I felt Donegal were the better team, and yet Mayo did enough to get themselves the draw that they needed with less than 15 seconds to go.
“But you have to complement Shaun Patton’s kick-out. It was a superb kick-out to young Moore and his energy to get forward was remarkable. He was outstanding for Donegal, I thought.
“I thought the undoing for Mayo, there were two things. The first half when they had the extra man, when Peadar Mogan was off (with a black card), they only managed to outscore Donegal three points to nil in that time. And it was a stage of the game where they didn’t make full impact of that.
“The second period was after they scored the goal with 15 minutes to go. I felt then Donegal showed their real quality. They went up and scored four points I think. Dáire Ó Baoill got a two pointer, but they really showed the mark of champions the way they went forward and got the vital scores.”
But Carney thought that Mayo were a little unlucky.
“Overall I thought Donegal were the better side but Mayo battled ferociously in the second half to get something from it and I thought they were unlucky not to get the draw at the very end. The draw would have seen them okay.”
Carney, who won two Ulster championships with Donegal before transferring to Mayo and winning four Connacht titles, felt the quality of the opening half was not as high as he would have expected.
“There were a lot of turnovers, a lot of slipping, a lot of misplaced passes. There were players rushing shots and that kind of stuff. Both teams struggled to settle down and one would have thought there was a huge amount of rain because there were so many slippages.
“But when they settled in the second half, when Mayo got a little bit more purposeful, a little bit more keen on attacking, I thought you had a much better game. But the first half, let's be honest about it, it was poor quality.”
Carney says there will be the usual post mortems in Mayo. “There will be huge disappointment being knocked out this early, 15th June. It’s an early stage to be gone from championship football. There will be a lot of wringing of hands and gnashing of teeth and that kind of stuff. The management, as far as I know, has another year to go. I don’t think now is the time to be speculating on that kind of stuff.
“Kevin McStay was taken ill and we wish him the best.”
As for the game of football under the new rules, Carney says it has improved.
“Overall it is a much better code than it was a year ago; it’s much better than it has been over the last 10 years. There’s a lot more willingness to get the forward but I still think neither team there today, and I think this applies generally, has come to terms with the new demands to kick the ball.
“I still think the hand pass to foot pass ratio is 3.2 to 1. I would love to see more purposeful kicking of the ball. And I think Mayo today, again and again, spurned opportunities to have a kick at goal, just holding on to possession for the sake of it. And in some ways I think it was their undoing.
“Overall I like the solo and go, I like the two points from outside the arc; I don’t like two points for frees outside the arc. It’s a game that has a lot more sense of adventure to it and a less emphasis on structure. Players seem to have a lot more permission to take the risk that you wouldn’t have had in the past. It is improving. It has room to go but it is certainly a lot better than we had.”
When put to him that it has been a bizarre championship with all teams now tasting at least one defeat, he agrees.
“It is a bizarre championship. I was looking at Kieran McGeeney (on Saturday) and he must have been wondering why did we not put Galway out of that championship. Galway got a stay of execution and they can still come back to haunt somebody.”