Mac's View: Sadness in Donegal this week and we don’t have any answers


It was a disappointing end to the Donegal GAA championship season with the defeat to Dublin on Sunday after extra-time and there were more questions than answers around afterwards.
It is just impossible to put a finger on what has happened to Donegal this year but a family friend from Cork, who was up for the game against Cork in Ballybofey, had commented after that game that Donegal were not playing as well as they were last year.
Why that was we just don’t know. We had a very good league campaign which was building nicely and we went to Croke Park and blew Kerry away in that final with some ease. It was almost the complete performance.
But it has been mostly downhill ever since that league final. We have lost three championship matches, two at home to Down and Cork and then on Sunday in Croke Park, we weren’t able to match Dublin when it was needed most.
Our players were running out of gas and looking on from the outside it is just a mystery. We all wondered what sort of training that might have been done in the week between the Cork game and against Dublin on Sunday last.
Personally, I would have had the squad in the salt water for most of those evenings and just sharpening up on shooting, etc. The hard work would have been done earlier in the year. Getting a team fresh for a big game in Croke Park is not easy, especially when some of them are carrying niggles, etc.
But it is what it is now. We will have no intercounty football for six or seven months and that is the disappointing aspect.
Did the National League campaign of eight games take more out of us than we thought? There was no particular reason why that should be. And this year we had the perfect run-in to the championship with four weeks between the League final and the Down game; another four weeks before Kerry and three weeks to the Cork game. It was nearly similar to what the old Ulster championship used to look like. So having too many games wasn’t a factor.
We had Michael Murphy playing as well as ever and probably one of the most consistent over the year. His equalising score was a marvellous effort but the row afterwards didn’t help Donegal's cause as we lost two of our best players.
They introduced Sean Guiden, who I believe is a son of Niall Guiden, who was one of Dublin’s best forwards in the 1992 All-Ireland final. Guiden made a huge difference, especially in extra-time. Donegal also had trouble dealing with Colm Basquel and Con O’Callaghan during the game and O’Callaghan will be a big loss to Dublin as he pulled the hamstring again at the end of normal time.
Going forward I would hope there would be no hasty decisions in the Donegal camp. I know Michael Murphy will be 37 shortly, but I would hope he would stay on.
As for Jim McGuinness, that will be up to Jim himself, but there is more in him. There is a lot of strain attached to management now at county level and I remember when I went back at 60 years of age, I ended up getting two stents.
There is a good break of six months now and time to recharge the batteries. There is a definite need for a fresh voice in the backroom team, a strong personality that will get Jim’s attention. It might also be good to have a voice in the stand. That was evident after last year’s All-Ireland final.
They say you learn more from defeats than from success. So it is important that there is a thorough examination of the past year and there will be a need to freshen the panel.
I felt there was a case for bringing in Jamie Brennan on Sunday and putting Murphy in at full-forward. Jamie is a good man to hang a goal and he will be disappointed that players that were substituted were brought back in ahead of him. But that is all in the past now. We have six months to get things sorted and the club championship will get some breathing space. That will give Jim the chance to get around to see who might be available to freshen things up.
Armagh also bit the dust at the weekend and Kerry looked awesome once more. I feel they will be too strong for Tyrone this weekend.
I fancy Cork to overcome Mayo in what should be a very tight game while I fancy Monaghan, with Jack McCarron and Rory Beggan on form, to get the better of neighbours Louth in what is a novel pairing.
The final game, Dublin v Galway is on Sunday evening and I have fancied Galway since the start of the year with their huge talent, especially up front. It is a sad week in Galway with the untimely passing of Paul Clancy, who would have played against us in the early noughties, especially that exciting All-Ireland quarter-final and replay in 2003, which I watched recently.
Finally, this week, my condolences to the Breslin family, Gaoth Dobhair, on the passing of Donal Breslin, with whom I played with and against. He was a month older than me and we go back a long time. His father was Ceann Comhairle in the Dáil. I remember meeting Gaoth Dobhair in a minor final in 1959 and we had Bernard Brady, Peter Quinn and Seamie Granaghan and were going well at half-time but Donal came out in the second half and beat us on his own. His son Donal (Dods) was also a good player and would have been on the 1992 panel if he had not emigrated. Ar dheis Dé ar a anam.
Brian McEniff was in conversation with Peter Campbell