MANUS BOYLE COLUMN: Postponing league games is dangerous precedent


It was an interesting call a few weeks back by the GAA to cancel some remaining fixtures in Division Four of the National League. Their statement read that “due to scheduled club fixtures (in one or both counties) in each case, it was not possible to reach agreement for the playing of these games, and they have therefore being declared null and void.”
The games affected were Waterford v Leitrim, Wicklow v Limerick and Laois v Antrim. The statement from the GAA went on to say: “It is regrettable that the exceptional weather conditions of recent weeks have given rise to this situation and while it would have been preferable that the games could have been rearranged before the conclusion of the league season, it was felt by the CCCC that this should not happen at the expense of pre-scheduled club games in April”.
The CCCC (Central Competitions Control Committee) had asked the counties affected to agree different dates on which to play the rearranged fixtures but no agreement could be reached by all involved so the CCCC were left with no option but to declare the games null and void.
What does this tell us about the games going forward? Is it because the GAA at central level made such a big thing about county players being available to their clubs in April that they were left with very little movement when it came to these games being cancelled?
What would it say if they decided to play the games in April? Those within those counties would come out and say that county comes first again. If we look at this idea, that county players should be made available for their clubs in April, are they telling us that they will not be available before or after April in the future? That county players will only be available for that one month and then after the county teams are finished in the championship?
Who made this rule; that players couldn’t decide for themselves? Yes, I understand the concept that the GAA are trying to give direction but by telling county managers that club players have to be only available in April gives them a much stronger say in when players actually do play for their clubs. Should anyone have that right in what is supposed to be an amateur game?
If the same scenario had arisen in Division One or Two, where the crowds attending are much bigger, would these games have been declared null and void? In making this decision - although I have no doubt not intentional - are the CCCC showing a lack of respect to the counties involved? Is there a perception that they are not treating them in the same way they would treat the likes of Dublin, Meath or Cork?
I agree they were caught between a rock and a hard place in this situation and regardless what agreement they came too, it would be wrong in the eyes of some, but this decision could set a very dangerous precedent for the future at both club and county level.
We are all aware that there are loads of meaningless games played at the end of club and national leagues, so are we saying now just because it will not have any effect on the outcome of relegation or promotion that we don’t finish out the competition?
When you consider the expense and time incurred by clubs and players in playing these games, is it okay no to play them? What message does that send?
By suggesting to younger players that if there is nothing at stake why bother playing the games, are we getting away from one of the principle core values that the GAA stands for, of representing your community regardless of what may or may not be at stake?
If club teams fail to fulfil a fixture they are fined, even at underage level, yet by not playing games at the highest level, intercounty level, there are no repercussions.
What message does it send out to the counties that are affected by the ruling? These teams are in Division Four and their county boards, clubs and players are doing their very best to promote and improve the game of football in their area. For the likes of Waterford, Wexford, Antrim and Limerick, where hurling is seen as the stronger of the two games, this must feel like another nail in the fight to promote football.
Laois, on the other hand, were going through a bad patch and winning promotion will have glossed over what happened but for the likes of Leitrim, how are they as a county supposed to promote the game when the perception could be taken, sure we’re only in Division Four, what do we matter? You would have to ask yourself if you were a player, coach, even in administration why would I bother?
Of course there are no winners in this. The CCCC were not going to win either way, because the fixture list is so congested; there is no space for any cancellations. However, not seeing out your fixture list sends out the wrong message, especially when it involved the teams that need the most support.