McShea’s Say: The exciting Patrick McBrearty will be a serious miss to Donegal


Patrick McBrearty battled hard over the years and has had some serious injuries, but his commitment and impact on Donegal never dropped as a result
It was a real blow to hear that Patrick McBrearty has had to retire from Donegal on medical advice in relation to a knee injury.
Patrick burst onto the scene at just 17 years old on a drizzly, dull day in Ballybofey when he turned out for both the minors and the seniors in one go.
The word at the time was that there was a seriously exciting prospect emerging from Kilcar, and I remember seeing him in an Under-16 game, and he took my breath away. As well as the skill, he was a huge teenager, built so powerfully.
He's battled hard over the years and has had some serious injuries, but his commitment and impact on Donegal never dropped as a result.
I remember Aussie Rules clubs were circling at the time, but just like Michael Murphy, Patrick turned down those advances. Patrick was so exciting to watch, and he'll be a serious miss for Donegal, both on the field and inside the dressing room.
What is in store for Donegal fans in 2026?
After what could be described as a year of misguided optimism by many loyal Donegal followers, I believe that a much more objective analysis of our team’s prospects as the new season is only a matter of weeks away will be the order of the day.
It was great to hold on to our Ulster title this year, but the implosion against Kerry in the All-Ireland final was a major disappointment, and the manner of that defeat has put a dent in the confidence that prevailed throughout the county.
The fact that we are second favourites behind Kerry is a clear indication of the regard for the quality of players at manager Jim McGuinness’ disposal, and they are a very talented squad, but runners-up is not good enough for Donegal currently.
The county championship was a little disappointing as there were few players who showed the form required to play and compete successfully in inter county football.
Four Masters are an exception in this regard as they have many players who have the skill to make a mark in a county jersey.
It may be a little early for some of them, but I always believed that if you were good enough, you were old enough.
Finnbarr Roarty really endorsed that theory with his wonderful football all the way through Ulster in his Donegal jersey. As always, when a new season beckons, there is much debate about the makeup of every county squad. Father time waits for no man, and there is inevitable speculation about some of our more senior players who have considerable mileage clocked up.
I do not believe that I am one to dramatise things or deliver fulsome praise, it is not in my makeup, and a man is either a good player or he is not. A few are great, and they deserve respect, but a real positive for Donegal as they look forward is the news that Michael Murphy is yet again to support his county, his availability is a major positive to our team’s prospects of success.
He is simply the greatest ever to wear his county jersey. He is a colossus. Whatever was needed, he had it. He is immensely powerful. He is prodigiously gifted in the arts and crafts of the game. His temperament is perfect, and his confidence is supreme and infectious.
To come back this year and be a contender for player of the year and achieve a coveted All-Star award was an incredible achievement. Very few players deliver on their second coming. The only other one that I remember was Dublin’s Jimmy Keaveney after Kevin Heffernan talked him into a change of heart in 1974, which culminated in Dublin winning the All-Ireland against a great Cork side against all the odds.
This is also a big year for our management team. After a semi-final defeat to Galway two years ago and a defeat in this year’s final, the expectations are still very high in Donegal.
Armagh and Tyrone haven’t gone away, while Monaghan’s incredible battling qualities were clearly on view in Scotown’s great win against Kilcoo on Saturday-Nationally the GAA faces a challenging year. Is it still a grassroots, amateur movement? Or has it become a machine for elite composition?
The decline in rural population is also a major issue, but the ability to survive many major crises is well documented.
As this is my last column in 2025, I would like to wish everyone a very happy and peaceful Christmas. While if driving, please take care, as the statistics for road deaths are something no family deserves to endure.