An Coimisíun Pleanála dismisses appeal against Lifford commercial shed


Donegal County Council had previously granted permission for the proposals to Maxlite Ireland Ltd in March
An Coimisíun Pleanála has upheld a Donegal County Council decision for a Lifford-based business to demolish a derelict dwelling and construct a commercial storage shed.
Maxlite Ireland Ltd were granted conditional permission for the proposals by Donegal County Council in March; however, an appeal was later lodged to An Coimisíun Pleanála.
An Coimisíun Pleanála decided by a majority of two to one to grant permission, generally in accordance with the positive recommendation of their Senior Planning Inspector, Elaine Power.
Established in 2017, Maxlite Ireland Ltd says it aims to bring “vision and passion for the highest quality, stylish, and on-trend lighting.”
Their proposed development comprises the demolition of an existing derelict dwelling (97.4sqm) and the construction of a single-storey commercial storage shed (80sqm) with a pitched roof with a maximum height of around 4.4m.
Currently, the site accommodates a derelict cottage which fronts directly onto O’Brien Row.
The lodged appeal stated that the derelict cottage should be restored, and noted that the site was next to a listed building in Lifford Garda Station, and was three metres from a historical plaque.
It was also argued that the proposed development was not suitable for the nearby laneway, that the laneway had no capacity for additional traffic, and that traffic caused vibrations to adjacent properties.
Furthermore, there were concerns that the “proposed development would negatively impact on the residential amenity of the appellant's property.”
In response, Donegal’s Planning Authority said the proposed development was a “less vulnerable development compared to the highly vulnerable use currently in situ,” and with the low shed height, no issues would arise “in relation to loss of privacy, overlooking or residential amenity.”
The Inspector’s report further highlighted that the existing cottage was not a protected structure, and was not listed on the National Inventory of Architectural Heritage, whilst the site was not located within an Architectural Conservation Area.
Ms Power recommended upholding Donegal County Council’s decision to grant planning permission for the proposals, with nine conditions.
She stated: “The proposed development would not seriously injure the residential or visual amenities of the area or of any adjacent property, would be acceptable in terms of traffic safety and convenience and built heritage.”