Donegal pensioner (77) played loud music at 2am and became verbally abusive to gardai

Gardai responded to a noise complaint at Bridge Street, Carndonagh.placeholder image
Gardai responded to a noise complaint at Bridge Street, Carndonagh. | (Iconic)

Elderly Carndonagh reveller escapes criminal conviction after judge agrees to apply the Probation Act

A 77-year-old Carndonagh pensioner who played loud music from his apartment in the early hours of the morning and later became verbally abusive towards gardaí has escaped a criminal conviction after a judge agreed to apply the Probation Act.

Daniel Doherty, of Apartment 6, Station House, Bridge Street, Carndonagh, appeared before Carndonagh District Court, sitting in Buncrana, where he pleaded guilty to a charge of being disorderly in a public place contrary to Section 5 of the Criminal Justice (Public Order) Act.

The court heard the incident occurred during the early hours of July 4, 2025, following complaints from residents about excessive noise coming from Mr Doherty’s apartment.

Prosecuting the case, Sergeant Conor Mulkerns outlined how gardaí were called to Bridge Street, Carndonagh at approximately 2am in response to a noise complaint.

Garda Jonathan Jacob attended the scene and spoke with Mr Doherty, who identified himself from an open window of his apartment.

Garda Jacob requested that he reduce the volume of music being played from the property after complaints had been received from neighbouring residents.

The court heard that Mr Doherty initially complied with the request and turned down the music. However, as gardaí were leaving the area, Mr Doherty exited his apartment into the car park at Bridge Street and became abusive towards the officers.

Sergeant Mulkerns said Mr Doherty was intoxicated and unsteady on his feet. He was directed on a number of occasions to return to his apartment but refused to do so.

As a result, he was arrested and later issued with a Fixed Charge Penalty Notice in relation to the offence.

The court heard that the penalty notice carried a fine of €120, which would increase to €180 if not paid within the prescribed period. The fine was never paid however and the matter subsequently proceeded before the court.

Defence solicitor Donough Cleary said he had spoken with the prosecution and was hopeful that the court would deal with the matter by way of the Probation Act rather than imposing a criminal conviction.

Mr Cleary said such an outcome would be appropriate in the circumstances of the case. He pointed out that his client was 77-years-old and had no previous convictions.

The solicitor added that Mr Doherty took issue with the description of him being intoxicated, although he accepted there had been an exchange with Garda Jacob.

“He accepts there was an exchange with Garda Jacob, but he says he wasn’t intoxicated,” Mr Cleary told the court.

The court also heard that following his arrest, Mr Doherty spent five-and-a-half hours in custody.

Mr Cleary acknowledged that his client had failed to pay the original fine but said he was an elderly man with limited financial means.

Sergeant Mulkerns confirmed he was not opposing the application for the Probation Act.

Judge Emile Daly marked the matter as “facts proven” and agreed to apply the Probation Act, meaning Mr Doherty has avoided a criminal conviction.

In delivering her decision, Judge Daly stressed that age alone was not the reason for the outcome.

“I apply the Probation Act, not on the basis of age, which would not be an appropriate reason of itself, but on the basis that there are no previous convictions, and there's no objection by the State,” she explained.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice