Donegal club championship makes it difficult to target Ulster and All-Ireland runs


Shane O’Donnell says there are some difficult hurdles for Donegal clubs to scale when it comes to plotting an Ulster Club SFC challenge.
The Donegal All-Star and his St Eunan’s teammates meet current provincial champions Scotstown on Saturday evening for a place in the final.
Since their re-emergence in 2013, the Monaghan outfit have absolutely dominated their own domestic championship, winning it 11 times in 14 seasons.
It’s the kind of traction that affords the Farney kingpins scope - the kind of latitude to look beyond Monaghan and directly at Ulster and, as some pundits are predicting this term, All-Ireland titles.
But Tír Chonaill champions St Eunan’s have an array of talent themselves and, like Magherafelt last time out, have the ability to not only put it up to Scotstown but, perhaps, even pull the rug.
Ciaran Moore, Niall O’Donnell and Shaun Patton are the other marquee names at boss Kieran Donnelly’s disposal, so the weekend’s clash at Brewster Park has the potential to be a real cracker.
Ahead of that tangle, Jim McGuinness’ silky No. 11, the one that will carry so much threat in Enniskillen at the weekend, sat down with Frank Craig to look at all of that and much more.
FC: You’re a teacher at Deele Secondary School, Raphoe. That’s a nice sort of triangle in terms of commuting for club and county.
SO’D: Yeah, it's actually worked out very well for me. You're outside the town, you're not really dealing with people or meeting them on the streets and stuff, which is nice. It’s great for training, obviously, as well. Whenever you're back in Convoy with Donegal, you can go straight from school and get your pre-training stuff done good and early. Then, with St Eunan's as well, you're able to get back to the house and chill out for a wee while before you go to training. I don't miss that Dublin run at all now, to be honest with you. At one stage, at college in DCU at the time, it was my first year in with Donegal and I was basically living out of a car. But it’s great being home now. You have a bit of a routine every day. You're well prepared for training, even in terms of getting your food and your bag organised and having a bit of downtime as well. You're not worried about driving back to Dublin or getting up early the next day. So it's a big help.
FC: Your brother Niall has been commuting to and from Chicago but missed the Erne Gaels win. Will we see him Saturday night?
SO’D: I honestly haven’t been chatting to him but I'm hoping he will be getting back for it. I know he was caught up at work and stuff for the last game, which is obviously the priority. He has to be very careful with the annual leave. Hopefully, we’ll have him back for it. Niall obviously has tons of experience. He's been playing senior since he was 16 or 17 and has been up with Donegal for roughly the last 10 years. He's just a good man to have involved. He knows what it's about and has been involved in all those big games throughout his years, which is obviously going to help with experience and help the younger lads who are on board this year.
FC: The Ulster Club Championship is a fantastic competition. But Donegal clubs often seem to find the going tough. Why is that?
“Yeah, it's funny, even back in the years when we weren't qualifying for Ulster, you'd be glued to the television watching some of those games because you know every game is going to be a great one. You have top teams going at it and different brands of football being played. I don't know if it's because of the time of year or what it is, but the Ulster Club Championship is probably one of the best competitions in Ireland, in my opinion. We haven't had a good run of it over the last couple of years, but we're happy with getting a result against Belleek. We're looking forward to a semi-final now, which is a first for a lot of that group. I suppose when you look back over the last couple of years in Ulster, the teams that have been dominating have been the teams that have been getting through their county championships on back-to-back occasions and even more times than that. Thinking of Scotstown, obviously, they've won the Monaghan Championship a lot of years over the last 15 or 20 years. I remember Slaughtneil on television back in the 2010s. Glen, out of Derry as well, beat us in O’Donnell Park a few seasons back and obviously went on to win All-Ireland and Ulster Championships as well. But you just can't take the Donegal Championship for granted. We had a tough quarter-final, semi-final and final. All three games could have gone either way, which shows how tight it is. The other side of the knockout draw with Kilcar, Glenswilly and Naomh Conaill, it was the exact same. It is tough, and it's a relief when you actually end up winning a county championship because of how hard it is. But the mindset has to be not to rest on your laurels. At this time of year, everybody is in good form because it's a bonus to still be training. Not many teams are training at this stage of the season, so it's always nice to be staying on.
FC: You really ran the likes of Glen Maghera and Errigal Ciarán so close in recent seasons. Do those results still grate when you reflect back?
Yeah, they are very thin. We lost to Errigal Ciarán in 2024 and they ended up getting to an All-Ireland final. Glen, under Malachy O’Rourke at the time, beat us and they got to two All-Ireland finals, back-to-back, and winning one. They were both games I look back on and still think we left it behind us. Even watching other Donegal teams like Naomh Conaill at different times, I think they narrowly got beaten by Glen as well one of those times. When you look back and see how those teams are faring in the All-Ireland series, it's probably something to take a positive outlook on. Obviously, you're disappointed as well because you see how close you were and what could have been in terms of picking up Ulster medals. Scotstown is obviously going to be a big ask. They played Naomh Conaill last year and could see what they were like. Even watching the Magherafelt game the last day, you could see how those two teams went at it.
FC: Kieran Donnelly, a little like Erne Gaels last time out, is also a former Scotstown boss. As well as being a phenomenal coach, that’s serious inside knowledge at his disposal as well.
SO’D: Yeah, Kieran has been brilliant and I’m really enjoying working with him, actually. I was obviously on board a lot earlier than I was hoping to be, with how early the season finished with Donegal, but everything has been going well so far. He's a great man to listen to. He's very good at getting his messages across to players and he comes across as a gentleman whenever you're listening to interviews or anything like that. Training is going very well and it's enjoyable, which is a big help as well. When it comes to the games, he tells you what to do in certain scenarios, but he does leave a lot up to us to put out the fires if we have to do this or that. So it is player-led in some sort of way, but it's a good balance at the minute. I'm obviously delighted to have him on board. I wouldn't have known him too well when I was younger, but I've known him over the last couple of years when he was involved with Fermanagh. He has a lot of club experience as well. And like you say, he has a brilliant CV and knows a lot about Ulster club football. And the hope is all of that can make the difference when it really matters, as the margins seem wafer-thin right now.
FC: When you come back into a club set-up, after what can often be a long stint with Donegal, can it be a tricky transition early on having missed a large chunk of the season?
SO’D: It's a funny one, yeah. It's tough at the start. You're coming back, maybe off the back of a holiday or having got a wee bit of downtime to yourself, while the club lads are upping the ante and getting geared towards championship football. It's funny when you come back. You're probably in worse shape than the boys down at the club because of how intense it is. From a mental approach, anyway. It's tough, I suppose. Again, you're jumping in with people you haven't seen for nearly the guts of a year. I know you went to school with these people and they're your best friends and things like that, but it can be tough when you haven't seen them in so long. You don’t want to come in and start talking right away. Once you get a week or two under your belt, everything kind of goes back to normal and how things were when you were younger and playing underage. It takes a couple of weeks, but you get there eventually. And with the Donegal championship a group phase one, and with us going on a run, it settles pretty quickly and the focus switches.
