Donegal fisherman to plead not guilty to alleged breaches of fisheries regulations


Book of Evidence served on Greencastle fisherman who has been sent forward for trial to Letterkenny Circuit Court
A Greencastle fisherman has been sent forward for trial to Letterkenny Circuit Court on charges relating to alleged breaches of fisheries regulations.
Hugh McClenaghan, of Ballymacarthur, Greencastle, faces two charges of failure to comply with Article 14 of Council Regulation (EC) and Article 47 of Commission Regulation (EC), by failing to transmit timely and accurate data in his fishing logbook.
The offences, which are alleged to have taken place whilst he was the master of the ‘Northern Celt’ fishing boat on two dates in September 2020, are in contravention of Regulation 5 of the Sea-Fisheries (Community Control System) Regulations 2016.
During a court hearing at Buncrana District Court, defence solicitor Ciaran MacLochlainn said his client strongly denies any wrongdoing in the matter and intends to contest the charges in full.
He indicated that Mr McClenaghan will be entering a plea of not guilty when the matter comes before the higher court.
State Solicitor Kieran Dillon told the court that the Book of Evidence had been served on the accused and that the Director of Public Prosecutions had directed that the case proceed to trial on indictment.
He confirmed that consent had been given for Mr McClenaghan to be sent forward to the next sitting of Letterkenny Circuit Court, which is due to commence on May 5.
Judge Emile Daly acknowledged that the Book of Evidence had been properly served and that the necessary legal formalities had been completed. Addressing the defendant, she issued what is known as an alibi warning, advising that if he intends to rely on an alibi as part of his defence, he must notify the State Solicitor in writing within 14 days.
The judge then formally returned Mr McClenaghan for trial by judge and jury to the Circuit Court on the two counts as outlined in the Book of Evidence.
Mr McClenaghan was released on continuing bail in the sum of €150, with no conditions attached.
Defence solicitor Mr MacLochlainn also applied for legal aid for two counsel in advance of the Circuit Court proceedings, citing the “very technical” nature of the case.
He told the court that similar issues involving other fishermen from the Greencastle area are currently before the Circuit Court, further underlining the complexity of the legal and regulatory matters involved.
