Pipe Dream? Donegal Ghost Estate faces fresh bid after 19 years


Moville ghost estate’s future hinges on sewage plan
Planning permission has been sought to finally complete a 19-year-old housing development in Carnagarve, Moville, which has remained unfinished and unoccupied for almost two decades.
Developer Samuel Norris has submitted an application for the installation of a new on-site sewage treatment system to serve four detached homes at the site, along with permission for the completion of all associated works on the partially completed estate.
The development was originally granted planning permission in 2007, with the four houses substantially completed in the years that followed. A subsequent application to complete the development was approved in 2018; however, the homes have never been occupied, and the site has remained dormant.
In documents submitted as part of the latest application, the developer states that he will take full responsibility for the operation and maintenance of the proposed sewage treatment system once installed.
The application further outlines that when all four homes are completed and occupied, a legal agreement will be put in place to allow a residents’ committee to take over responsibility for the long-term management and maintenance of the treatment facility.
A similar proposal was refused by the Planning Authority last year. In its refusal, the authority stated that Uisce Éireann was “currently preparing advice regarding their role in ensuring public water and wastewater infrastructure meets the necessary standards before it is taken in charge.”
The refusal also noted that the site and treatment systems would need to comply with Irish Water’s codes of practice for new infrastructure before any taking-in-charge process could proceed.
At the time, planners concluded that it would be “premature to permit the proposed development pending the publication of the advice” and said that granting permission would be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
Donegal County Council is now considering the new application, and a decision is expected to be made by the middle of June.