Greencastle fishing company fined €1,800 for hiring non-EU fisherman without permit

Greencastle firm, MCD Trawling Ltd, has been fined for a breach of employment regulations.placeholder image
Greencastle firm, MCD Trawling Ltd, has been fined for a breach of employment regulations.

“They made one mistake by employing this man in an attempt to help out a colleague in trouble” - says defence solicitor

A Greencastle-based fishing company has been convicted and fined €1,800 at Buncrana District Court for breaching employment permit legislation after employing a non-EU fisherman without the required authorisation.

MCD Trawling Ltd, with an address at Shilling Hill, Greencastle, pleaded guilty to a single charge under the Employment Permits Act 2006.

The case centred on the employment of a Ghanaian national on two of the company’s vessels during 2022 without a valid employment permit.

The court heard evidence from Workplace Inspector Tom Hayes, who carried out an inspection of the company in January 2023 to assess compliance with employment permit regulations.

During the inspection, he met with the company secretary and was provided with documentation relating to employees.

Mr Hayes told the court that records showed the Ghanaian national had been employed as a fisherman on two vessels operated by the company – the ‘St Catherine Laboure’ and the ‘Foyle Fisher’ – over a period of months in 2022.

As the individual was a non-EU national, Mr Hayes sought evidence of a valid employment permit, but none was produced.

The inspector noted that the company director, Mr Michael Gillen, was not present at the time of the inspection, but he later met with him to discuss the matter further.

During that meeting, Mr Gillen confirmed that the man had been employed on the vessels and acknowledged that a permit was required. However, he accepted that no valid permission had been in place during the relevant period.

The court was told that MCD Trawling Ltd had previously applied for employment permits for a number of non-EU workers, including the individual in question. However, those permissions had been rescinded by the Department of Justice on February 1, 2022.

Despite this, the Ghanaian fisherman continued working on the vessels.

Mr Hayes said that, aside from this particular breach, the company appeared to be compliant in other respects.

A number of foreign nationals were employed by MCD Trawling Ltd, but all other workers had the appropriate permissions in place. The court also heard that the individual involved has since obtained permission to work with another company.

State Solicitor Kieran Dillon, prosecuting, outlined that the offence fell under the Employment Permits Act 2006 and carried a maximum penalty of €3,000. He said the court had discretion to impose a lesser fine depending on the circumstances.

Defending solicitor Ciaran MacLochlainn said his client had initially intended to contest the charge but ultimately decided to enter a guilty plea. He outlined a number of mitigating factors on behalf of the company and its director.

Mr MacLochlainn told the court that Mr Gillen had taken on the Ghanaian fisherman as a favour to another skipper who had encountered difficulties and was unable to provide work for him at the time.

He also pointed to significant changes in employment legislation affecting non-EU fishermen during that period, which led to delays and backlogs in the processing of permit applications.

According to the defence, these delays created serious difficulties for operators in the fishing industry, effectively making it extremely challenging to recruit and retain non-EU crew members.

Mr MacLochlainn said his client had previously always ensured the necessary permissions were in place and had been caught out by the evolving regulatory framework and administrative delays.

The solicitor also highlighted a series of personal and financial hardships experienced by Mr Gillen in recent times. He told the court that one of the company’s vessels, the St Catherine Laboure, sank off Rockall in June 2024, approximately 220 nautical miles west of the Outer Hebrides.

While all six crew members were safely rescued, the vessel, valued at around €2.5 million, was lost.

Mr MacLochlainn said the incident had a profound impact on Mr Gillen, who has since been diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder. A medical report was submitted to the court in support of this.

In addition, he said Mr Gillen’s home had to be demolished in 2025 due to mica-related structural issues, adding further strain.

The court also heard that there is an ongoing dispute with the company’s insurer regarding the loss of the St Catherine Laboure, with no payout having been made to date.

Mr MacLochlainn described the Greencastle company as being under severe financial pressure as a result of these cumulative issues.

He emphasised that MCD Trawling Ltd had been a responsible employer over the years and had always operated within the law. He said the breach represented a single lapse in otherwise compliant practices and occurred in the context of trying to assist a fellow skipper.

“They made one mistake by employing this man in an attempt to help out a colleague in trouble,” he said.

Mr MacLochlainn also noted that Mr Gillen had cooperated fully with the investigation and had no previous convictions. He suggested that his client would be willing to make a charitable donation to the RNLI in lieu of a conviction.

However, Judge Emile Daly rejected that proposal, stating that such an approach was not appropriate in this case. Delivering her decision, she said the offence warranted a formal conviction.

The judge emphasised that employers in the fishing industry are subject to the same legal obligations as any other sector when it comes to employment permits.

She said it was clear that the company was aware that non-EU nationals required valid permissions to work and that this requirement had not been met.

Judge Daly convicted MCD Trawling Ltd and imposed a fine of €1,800, allowing six months for payment. She also fixed recognisance in the sum of €450 in the event of an appeal.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice