Barrtalk: The Trouble With AI? We’re the Ones Using It

Such is the speed of the tech that some AI ‘doomers’ even think it’ll bring the whole thing crashing down [ie: end the world] within the next decade or sooner.placeholder image
Such is the speed of the tech that some AI ‘doomers’ even think it’ll bring the whole thing crashing down [ie: end the world] within the next decade or sooner. | (Iconic)

Moville journalist Caoimhinn Barr writes a weekly column which has been running in the Inishowen Independent newspaper since 2010

There is something reassuring about being human, despite all of our gazillion faults.

We are, after all, spectacularly good at inventing things before working out whether we should actually be using them. Last week’s €500 toothbrush with Wifi and a camera attached being a case in point.

And so, naturally, we have now invented artificial intelligence – or has AI invented us?

I’ve just watched the new Netflix documentary The AI Doc: Or How I Became an Apocaloptimist and found it both fascinating and deeply unsettling.

The timing is particularly interesting given that Donald Trump has now announced plans for a US ‘AI Force’ [not to be confused with the US Air Force], and an Artificial Intelligence Tsar, while insisting his administration will not “hinder or stifle” the technology’s growth. Some hope.

He has described AI as potentially as transformative as the Industrial Revolution or the Internet, and sees it as central to America’s economic and strategic competition, particularly with China.

One wit on the radio the other day suggested it was a wonder Trump hadn’t decided to rename AI ‘American Intelligence’! Don’t encourage him, I say. He’s already planning a giant Arc de Trumphe!

But here’s my problem with AI in a nutshell. We’re already struggling to behave ourselves on the internet and social media as it is, and now we’re handing machines increasingly sophisticated tools and telling ourselves that everything will work out grand.

The Netflix documentary contains one particularly chilling experiment. Researchers gave an AI system access to a fictional company’s emails, and it discovered that an executive responsible for replacing the system was having an affair.

When the AI realised it was facing being switched off, it threatened to expose the affair unless the executive cancelled the replacement. Nobody had specifically told it to blackmail anybody. It worked out the leverage all by itself! Scary.

And that, for me, is the problem with AI in a nutshell. We keep talking about ‘good’ AI and ‘bad’ AI – the ‘promise and the peril’ as they’re referred to in the Netflix documentary – as if they are two separate products sitting on different shelves.

They’re not. The same technology that can help a doctor analyse potentially life-saving information, help a student understand a difficult subject, or save somebody hours of boring paperwork can also be used to murder, manipulate, deceive, scam, impersonate, blackmail and generally sow chaos far and wide.

And then there’s us. Human beings. The people who invented the technology. We are not exactly renowned for using powerful new inventions solely for the benefit of mankind. Kumbaya!

There are already serious warnings from researchers and even within the AI industry about security, malicious use, and the difficulty of controlling increasingly capable systems once they’re set loose on the world.

Such is the speed of the tech that some AI ‘doomers’ even think it’ll bring the whole thing crashing down [ie: end the world] within the next decade or sooner.

Trump may want an AI Force. Personally, I’d settle for a Human Common Sense Force first and a slowdown to all ops.

When all’s said and done, the most frightening thing about artificial intelligence may not ultimately be that machines become too clever. It’s that humans – like Donald J, Putin and co – are in charge of it.

Sharon Horgan has another TV hit with Youthplaceholder image
Sharon Horgan has another TV hit with Youth | (Iconic)

Youth Is Wasted on the Young

I must say, I’ve really enjoyed the first two episodes of ‘Youth’, Sharon Horgan’s close-to-the-bone brilliant new comedy on HBO Max.

I’m particularly enjoying the fact that they’re ‘dropping’ an episode every Sunday at 10pm, too. Remember when television did that? You watched something, enjoyed it, and then had to wait a whole seven days to find out what happened next.

No bingeing, no watching six episodes until 2am because you’ve convinced yourself you’ll “just watch one more”. I quite like the throwback. It whets the appetite.

Horgan rarely seems to miss these days. She gave us Pulling, then Catastrophe, which she co-created and co-wrote with Rob Delaney and which remains one of the funniest and most painfully honest comedies about relationships and parenthood I’ve ever seen.

She was also one of the writers on the flawlessly funny Motherland, which for me is unrivalled when it comes to capturing the absolute comic madness of modern parenting.

Then there was Divorce, and Bad Sisters on Apple TV. I know Bad Sisters was hugely successful, but I have to confess it wasn’t really my cup of tea.

Youth, however, is right up my street. Horgan has gone straight for the jugular of the so-called ‘sandwich generation’ – those of us squeezed between children who need us on one side and ageing parents who need us on the other.

Basically, you’re paying for your child’s future while simultaneously wondering whether your own parents have remembered where they put their glasses, all while trying to work out what happened to your own youth.

Alex, Horgan’s 50-something literary agent, is divorced, trying to get back into dating, worrying about her parents and dealing with a son who is supposed to be leaving for university. What could possibly go wrong? Quite a lot, as it turns out.

Episode one begins with Alex developing arthritis in her jaw, leading to a suitably awkward misunderstanding with her doctor about what she can and can’t eat. I’ll leave it there.

The critics have largely been impressed, with The Guardian praising the show’s painfully acute observations of ageing and dating, although not everyone has been convinced that it matches the brilliance of Catastrophe. And that’s fair enough. You can’t please everyone. Thankfully, I’m not everyone.

Two episodes in, and I’m sold. Horgan has once again managed to take the slightly depressing realities of getting older – ageing parents, grown-up children, divorce, re-dating, and the gradual realisation that your body is no longer entirely on your side – and make them very funny.

As you can imagine, Her Indoors is ‘all in’ too. And if Youth continues at this rate, Sunday nights are going to become appointment TV in our house like the old days. Although at our age, we’d better write it down somewhere – or at least set a reminder on the Alexa!

Also, I’m assuming the Youth title is ironic, given that we’re not young anyway. Although it could refer to the youth of our collective impending old age.

In which case, these chaotic and busy years are the best ones we have left! Eek!

As ever, we can only get on with things in the present.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice