Kayaker who went missing of Donegal coast almost reached dry land, inquest hears
.jpeg?trim=27,0,79,0&crop=&width=640&quality=70&enable=upscale)

Ministerial consent was required to hold the inquest, given that the kayaker’s remains were sadly never recovered
A kayaker who went missing in 2024 was last seen within a few hundred yards from safety having been at sea in somewhat challenging conditions, an inquest heard.
An inquest into the death of Paul Buchanan, a 57-year-old man from Ramelton, returned a finding of accidental death by drowning. The inquest heard that conditions were difficult on the evening of October 3, 2024, and that Mr Buchanan is believed to have almost made it back to Magheragallon Pier, Gweedore. His kayak was found north of Tory Island the following afternoon.
Despite an extensive, multi-agency search of shore, sea and islands, Mr Buchanan’s remains were never recovered.
The Coroner’s Court sitting at Letterkenny Courthouse on Wednesday, August 12 was presided over by Donegal coroner, Dr Denis McCauley. He explained that while it was unusual to hold an inquest in the absence of a body having been recovered, the circumstances were provided for under Section 23 of the Coroners Act.
Section 23 states: “Whenever a coroner has reason to believe that a death has occurred in or near his district in such circumstances that an inquest is appropriated and that, owing to the destruction of the body or its being irrecoverable, an inquest cannot be held except by virtue of this section, the Minister may, if he so thinks proper, direct an inquest in relation to the death to be held by that coroner or another coroner and thereupon the coroner so directed shall hold an inquest in relation to the death in like manner as if the body were lying within his district and had been viewed by him.”
A preliminary evidential hearing was held in July 2025, which paved the way for the inquest to take place.
Dr McCauley said: “Looking at the evidence that we did have, we decided to conduct a proof of life investigation. That was carried out by Inspector Mick Doherty. He did an extensive investigation.
With that and the evidence that Garda [Felicia] Coll had from her investigation, we then submitted a request to the Minister For Justice Jim O’Callaghan asking if he would allow me to open an inquest under Section 23.”
The minister directed that an inquest could go ahead.
The deposition of Mr Buchanan’s wife Bernadette was read into evidence by Sergeant Michael Kilcoyne.
In her deposition, she recalled how, on the morning of October 3, 2024 as she was leaving for work, her husband was standing looking out the window at a beautiful day.
“He said not to make dinner as he was kayaking in the evening and would get a take away,” she said.
Mrs Buchanan outlined her husband’s experience of kayaking on the river in Ramelton, at Inch, and on Mulroy Bay.
She described him as a keen water activity participant who also enjoyed adventure activities including kayaking, walking and cycling.
His work as an internal auditor with the Credit Union brought him to many places in Donegal. He was always keen to hear about good places for walking and other activities, and he would convey this information to his wife.
She added that he loved Gweedore, where he was working on the day in question.
“He tried to squeeze as much into every day as he could,” said Mrs Buchanan. “He squeezed so much into his life, and my life and the lives of our sons.”
When her husband did not make contact or return home that evening, she contacted the emergency services.
Dr McCauley asked if Mr Buchanan would normally kayak by himself or with others.
Mrs Buchanan replied that in Ramelton he would kayak with others, and sometimes went out with his sons.
“But if it was a case that it was a nice day and he was heading off to Gweedore or somewhen nice, he would get out for a kayak on his own,” she said. “It was just his way of relaxing after a day's work.”
The coroner asked if Mr Buchanan had kayaked from Magheragallon frequently.
Mrs Buchanan was unsure as she was unfamiliar with the Gweedore area.
“The first time I ever recall being in Magheragallon was for the vigil organised by Gweedore Credit Union,” she said.
Annemarie Coll, manager of Gweedore Credit Union, was next to give evidence. Her deposition was read into the inquest by Sergeant Kilcoyne.
She said that she had known Mr Buchanan for more than 20 years. He was in the Credit Union that day for the quarterly internal audit.
He left in the afternoon and had appeared to be in good spirits.
The next deposition to be read was that of local fisherman Proinsias Gallagher who was on Gola Island at 5pm, hauling his fishing gear.
“I happened to be looking in towards the mainland,” he said. “I seen a red kayak about halfway between Gola and Magheragallon Pier. It was going towards Inishmeane Island. The person did not seem to be showing any signs of being in difficulty.
“Next morning I went down to Bunbeg Pier and heard that a kayaker had not returned. I informed someone at the pier that I had seen a kayaker.”
Dr McCauley asked the witness if he could describe the water conditions in the area from the point of view of use by kayakers.
“It would be a very busy area in summer, a lot of kayakers on and off that would set out from there,” said Mr Gallagher.
He said there were not any bad currents.
Asked about the weather, the witness said it was a choppy sort of an evening.
“Not maybe the best of an evening to be kayaking, in my opinion,” he said. “As you would go out, it would get worse because the wind was blowing from the shore. When the kayaker had turned to come back home, it wouldn’t have been that nice.”
The inquest then heard the depositions of sisters Ann Breslin and Peg Sweeney who were staying in their respective holiday homes on Gola.
Ann was preparing dinner at 6.30pm when she noticed a person in a kayak.
“I couldn’t believe it as it was a messy evening to be out in a kayak,” she said. “I rang my sister.”
The women met up and observed the kayaker from a house belonging to their niece as it had a better view. The kayaker had gone out of sight but then returned, and was heading back towards Magheragallon.
“We watched him with the lights on,” said Ann Breslin.
Once the kayaker reached a point within a few hundred yards of the pier, the sisters returned home and continued preparing dinner.
When asked by the coroner about her shock at seeing a kayaker in the conditions, Ms Breslin elaborated: “The sea was getting heavier. It would be very unusual to see someone going out. The sea was rising.”
She recalled her unease at watching the kayaker go around the corner of Gola and out of sight.
“You know when you see someone alone, especially in a kayak, you look out for someone. I was looking out for him, and he did come back.”
Dr McCauley asked how close had been to the pier at her last observation.
“There was still a little bit of work to be done, but he must have been close enough to the pier, and I thought, ‘Thank goodness you are home.’”
Ms Sweeney agreed in her evidence, saying: “We could see the person moving along and didn’t see any signs of trouble. We were there for about 20 minutes and all seemed ok.”
Both women stayed at Peg Sweeney’s home that night. Ms Sweeney awoke at 1.30am and noticed lights on the pier and heard the rescue helicopter.
Timmy Boyle was Officer in Charge of Bunbeg Coast Guard when the tragedy occurred. He gave evidence of answering the call regarding a missing kayaker minutes before midnight, and he outlined in detail the extensive search that ensued, with units from Bunbeg, Arranmore, Lough Swilly and Tory, as well as three helicopters, drone operators, a fixed wing aircraft, a sub aqua unit, and local boats.
Mr Buchanan’s kayak was located 5km north of Tory the following afternoon, almost 24 hours after he had last been seen. The search for the missing kayaker continued into the ensuing days and weeks.
“After 21 days of searching for Paul Buchanan, the search was stood down,” said Mr Boyle.
Dr McCauley asked: “When do you start to worry that you are not going to find the person?”
Mr Boyle replied: “Not until you stop searching. You are always hoping.”
He explained that although the kayak was found north of Tory Island, that was not an indicator that Mr Buchanan’s remains had travelled the same distance or in the same direction. The kayak on the water’s surface would have been blown by winds, while a body in the water would have been subjected to tides and currents. And although Mr Buchanan had been wearing a personal flotation device, this would not have kept him on the surface for 24 hours.
Garda Felecia Coll from Bunbeg Garda Station gave evidence of receiving a call shortly after 9.30pm on October 3, 2024, saying that a kayaker had failed to return home to Ramelton.
“I was given details of his red Suzuki Vitari,” she said.
Garda Coll said that Mrs Buchanan and gardaí had tried to contact Mr Buchanan to no avail. She arranged to meet Dungloe gardaí at Cruit but decided first to check Magheragallon, where she found the unoccupied vehicle of Mr Buchanan.
“The back seats were down, there was a towel on the dashboard showing that the kayak had likely been within,” said Garda Coll.
“There was no sign of anyone at Magheragallon Pier, nor of the kayak or paddle.
“Search operations commenced.”
Dr McCauley asked the garda what her recollection was of the weather on the evening that Mr Buchanan went missing.
“I don’t really recall the weather earlier,” she said. “When I got out of the patrol car at Mageragallon it was wild and dark and windy.”
Having heard the evidence, Dr McCauley pieced together a timeline of events whereby Mr Buchanan left Gweedore Credit Union in the late afternoon, and entered the water at Magheragallon Pier between 5pm and 5.30pm. He was seen by the witnesses on Gola Island around 6.30pm, and they watched him for around 40 minutes.
Inspector David Hannigan presented details of the proof of life investigation that was carried out by Inspector Mick Doherty at the direction of the coroner.
He confirmed that Mr Buchanan was in possession of his mobile phone at the time of his disappearance and it had not since been located, nor had there been any activity on the phone.
Inquiries into Mr Buchanan’s financial accounts had shown no actions whatsoever. His Irish passport was furnished to gardaí by his wife, and no new passport application was made. Mr Buchanan had been born in the UK, and it was confirmed that he was not in possession of a UK passport.
Inspector Hannigan continued: “Taxi drivers and bus operators were canvassed. No person matching Mr Buchanan's description attempted to use their services.
“His activity on the evening was not out of the ordinary due to his active lifestyle.
“This is being treated as a tragic drowning incident by An Garda Síochana. There has been no trace whatsoever since that evening.”
Dr McCauley said the witnesses collectively had given all the information possible, and he thanked them for their input.
“Paul Buchanan died on October 3, 2024,” said the coroner. “Unfortunately his body was never recovered. We have heard enough evidence to say that Mr Buchanan died on that evening. There was no third party involved.”
He recorded the medical cause of death as drowning, adding: “From a descriptive point of view, an extensive garda investigation showed nothing extraordinary about this. This was an accidental death.”
He said the inquest had been conducted under a section of the Coroners Act that was not normally used, and that it would allow a death certificate to be issued to Mr Buchanan’s family.
“But more importantly, I think it is good that we get as much information as we can and present it to them so that they can understand what happened,” said Dr McCauley.
“He did what he loved doing and unfortunately on that evening an accident occurred.”
The coroner expressed his condolences to Mr Buchanan’s bereaved family, as did Sergeant Kilcoyne on behalf of An Garda Síochana.
“I hope that today has given you some answers,” said the sergeant.
Solicitor Marshall McCloughan spoke on behalf of the Buchanan family, thanking Dr McCauley and those involved in the inquest, the investigation and the extensive search.
“It is very much appreciated by the family,” said Mr McCloughan.
Dr McCauley had a special word of thanks for the emergency services and those involved in searches at sea.
“It is important that we look at what the emergency services do all over the country when a tragedy like this happens,” he said. “A lot of volunteers come together within minutes for searches at sea.
“When we hear the helicopter going, when everything kicks into action, we have to be really proud of what they do and we have to be really thankful of what they do, and for all the emergency services, gardaí, all paramedics, we should be very appreciative.