‘Proof that government has gotten it so wrong on defective blocks’


Ward, MacLochlainn and Doherty back Dail motion for urgent action, as families are “locked into irreversible decisions using incomplete science”
Donegal TDs Pádraig MacLochlainn, Pearse Doherty and Charles Ward have raised the need for a review of the Defective Concrete Block Remediation Scheme, given the publication of a new National Standards Authority of Ireland standard.
They say the standard proves the government has been misdiagnosing the problems with homes and buildings for years.
The Deputies were speaking as they co-signed a motion put forward in the Dáil calling for immediate action from the government.
Deputy MacLochlainn said: “The decisions that led to this absolute disaster emanated from this chamber. Time and again, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael government ministers were challenged about the regulation of the construction industry over the years. Again and again, they failed to properly regulate and oversee that industry.”
“The government want to move on. They want to say: ‘We are on top of this,' 'See that protest that led to 20,000 people, we've all moved on now from that’.”
“Be very, very clear, it is just the beginning of the realisation of the scale. I can tell you there are housing estates in Donegal where only about 10 or 15 per cent of homes are being rebuilt – all of those houses need to be rebuilt.”
“So I am saying to you now, there will be tens of thousands of properties that will need to be rebuilt, and it will be a massive, massive amount of money that will impact us for generations thanks to the people in this chamber who made those decisions.”
Teachta Doherty said the reality is that the government has gotten it so wrong.
“For many, many years we have stood in this house and in committees, and we have told the government that you are analysing the wrong problem and as a result you are coming up with the wrong solutions.”
“There are so many people now in my county and others that have been told that the remedy is now flawed. Outerleaf - nonsense. Partial demolition - nonsense. Downgrading of their assessments - absolutely nonsense. But government refused to listen over and over again.”
“And you continue with the misery, the pain and the hardship because you still will not recognise what needs to be done here. What needs to be done here is a full 100 per cenr redress scheme and an end-to-end scheme.”
Meanwhile, Deputy Charles Ward warns that families are being “locked into irreversible decisions on homes using incomplete science”.
A major Dáil motion led by the 100% Redress Party TD has intensified scrutiny of how the State’s defective concrete framework is applying I.S.465:2026, particularly in cases involving foundation retention.
At the centre of the motion is an explicit admission within the State’s own technical standard:
“The state of knowledge relating to foundations is insufficient to provide guidance for certain combinations of aggregate and active ISA risk factors.”
Ward says the passage of the motion reflects growing concern that decisions with irreversible consequences are being made on the basis of acknowledged scientific uncertainty.
“This is the State’s own standard, saying it does not fully understand certain foundation conditions,” he said. “Yet those same conditions are still being used to make irreversible decisions about people’s homes.”
The motion also notes that the standard confirms testing does not provide a full evaluation of foundation condition, meaning uncertainty remains embedded in the assessment process rather than eliminated by it.
Ward said the issue is not that uncertainty exists – but how it is treated.
“The precautionary principle must apply. If the science is incomplete and the consequences are irreversible, you do not pass that risk on to homeowners.”
The motion calls for an independent international review of I.S.465:2026, publication of the evidential basis for foundation retention decisions, and a review of whether homeowners are being left carrying long-term structural risk arising from scientific limitations in the standard.
