Search

06 Sept 2025

Penalty heartbreak as Abbey VS, Donegal Town lose out to Rice College in All-Ireland semi-final

Abbey boys come back from 2-0 down but then lose out in the penalty shoot-out in McSharry Park

Penalty heartbreak as Abbey VS, Donegal Town lose out to Rice College in All-Ireland semi-final

The Abbey VS team pictured before the semi-final

Abbey VS, Donegal Town bowed out of the Tom Ticher All-Ireland competition (U-17) when they went down 3-2 on penalties to Rice College, Westport at Ray McSharry Park, Sligo.

Abbey VS 2
Rice College 2
(Rice College won 3-2 on pens)

It was a sickening way to lose with Abbey missing their first two penalties while Rice College converted their first two. David Monaghan and Aaron McGrory converted while Abbey VS 'keeper Peadar Shallow saved the fourth Rice College spot kick.
But the game was decided when Abbey missed their fifth kick which left the Mayo college winners on the day.

Overall, it was a very entertaining and closely contested game with Rice College the much bigger side physically. But in terms of skill, Abbey VS held the edge with 14-year-old Turlough Carr outstanding at left back.

Robbie Murphy was almost in but his touch past the 'keeper went wide while Seanan Carr had an effort that went over.
Both sides had chances in the opening minutes but it was Rice College who took the lead when Cian Halpin got in behind the Abbey defence to fire home on 31 minutes.

The Donegal Town boys had claims for a hand ball immediately after when Seanan Carr crossed. It got worse for the Donegal side when they failed to clear a corner and Adam Nugent headed back across goal and Noah Massey couldn't miss from a yard out.

Kevin Muldoon heads the ball forward for Abbey in McSharry Park


Abbey were given a lifeline a minute from the break when he chased down a pass back and blocked the 'keeper's clearance into the net.

Abbey were back level 17 minutes into the second half when a great ball from Jake Graham over the top found Robbie Murphy and he cleverly chipped the advancing keeper.
Both sides had chances with Abbey's best chance coming when a Daniel McIntyre effort was fumbled by the Rice 'keeper but his crossbar saved him.



It went to extra-time and Ruairi McLaughlin was just off target but it was mainly a backs-to-the-wall time for the Abbey defence, who were outstanding. Matthew Gallagher, who came in at half-time, was heroic alongside Jake Graham, while Aaron McGrory let little past.
And in the final seconds 'keeper Peadar Shallow twice denied the Rice College captain, Adam Nugent.
So it went to the dreaded penalties and it was Rice College who went through.

The Abbey boys gave their all with Robbie Murphy working so hard up front; Seanan Carr was always a threat while in midfield David Monaghan, Kevin Muldoon, Caolan Sweeney and Ruairi McLaughlin were pittied against a very tall and physical Westport side. The Abbey replacements, Daniel McIntyre, Eoghan Carr and especially Matthew McGinty performed really well.
Abbey VS manager, Mark Young, said he was very pleased with the way his side performed.
"We couldn't have asked any more of them. They were out on their feet at the end with cramp," said Young.
"We did really well to come back after Rice College started well. Robbie Murphy got a brace for us; the goal before half-time got us back in the match.

"It is an awful way to lose a game, to penalties, but the boys gave their all.
"The did the school and their parents proud," said Young, who said it has been a good year for the school.
"It was our first Ulster final win, but we should be contesting these games on a regular basis and hopefully this will help and we can kick on," said Young.

ABBEY VS, DONEGAL: Peadar Shallow, Aaron McGrory, Turlough Carr, Reuben Amoo, Jake Graham, David Monaghan, Kevin Muldoon, Coalan Sweeney, Seanan Carr, Ruair McLaughlin, Robbie Murphy. Substitutes: Matthew McGinty, Daniel McIntyre, Kernan Deignan, Eoghan Gallagher, Aron Carr.

RICE COLLEGE, WESTPORT: Conor Meaney, Noah Massey, Cillian McGing, Conor Reynolds, Conor Kelly, Lorcan Silke, Cian Gill, Fionn O'Hora, Adam Nugent, Conor Cannon, Cian Halpin. Substitutes: Fionn O'Ruain, Daniel O'Malley, Killian McTaggart, Sean Gannon, Evan Durkan.

REFEREE: John Barry (Sligo)

Matthew McGinty sends Abbey VS on the attack against Rice College

To continue reading this article,
please subscribe and support local journalism!


Subscribing will allow you access to all of our premium content and archived articles.

Subscribe

To continue reading this article for FREE,
please kindly register and/or log in.


Registration is absolutely 100% FREE and will help us personalise your experience on our sites. You can also sign up to our carefully curated newsletter(s) to keep up to date with your latest local news!

Register / Login

Buy the e-paper of the Donegal Democrat, Donegal People's Press, Donegal Post and Inish Times here for instant access to Donegal's premier news titles.

Keep up with the latest news from Donegal with our daily newsletter featuring the most important stories of the day delivered to your inbox every evening at 5pm.