READ THE REID: Tyrone are best team in country to put it up to Dubs

placeholder image

Dublin and Tyrone will contest this year’s All-Ireland senior football championship final on September 2nd. On Saturday evening last Dublin swept aside Galway with a decisive victory while Tyrone beat Ulster neighbours Monaghan by a single point in the other semi-final last Sunday. The Dublin versus Galway contest was very much one-sided as expected while Tyrone and Monaghan played out a tactical and tense game.

Dublin were always in control against a much-improved Galway team though they were always playing catch-up against a fluent and very fit Dublin outfit. It seemed as though Dublin were still playing in third gear and never really had to extend themselves against the Tribesmen. Galway did manage to breach the Dublin rearguard on numerous occasions but their finishing left a lot to be desired. At least we know that Dublin are not invincible and Galway were able to expose many of their weaknesses. Galway are an emerging team who are doing well to mix it with the top guns. They still lack that power and finesse to pose a serious threat. Their performance was certainly no disgrace and I feel that they will only improve with time. They are in a similar position to ourselves, going through a transition just now.

Meanwhile, Tyrone and Monaghan didn’t disappoint when they squared up to each other in the other decider. The quality of football wasn’t exceptional because the game was played with players in each other’s faces. It was always going to be this type of game. Tyrone were the better team throughout but squandered chance after chance which could have cost them dearly in the final analyses.

Again, Mickey Harte got this game right tactically. I thought that Tyrone were technically better too and physically out-muscled a very tenacious Monaghan team. That said, this could have been an altogether different game had Monaghan taken the two goal chances that they created. Tyrone’s defence endured and were quite solid throughout. I thought that Colm Cavanagh was excellent and covered an awful lot of ground. On the day, Tyrone’s experienced players such as Peter Harte, Tiernan McCann, Colm Cavanagh and Mattie Donnelly took charge for the O’Neill county.

Although the scoreline suggests that this was a close affair, it has to be said that Tyrone should have won by a far bigger margin. Poor finishing let them down on several occasions. Monaghan, too, were guilty of having some wild shots at vital times. I feel that Tyrone are the best team in the country equipped to take on the reigning All-Ireland champions, Dublin. They have a great mix of youth and experience. They will match Dublin for physicality and fitness. I just feel that Tyrone need to be more disciplined in their defensive tackling and be more patient in front of the posts. Mickey Harte has used a lot of players in the championship to date. Given the strong bench that they have, it will be difficult to pick the best starting team. There’s no doubt that both Dublin and Tyrone will use their full complement of substitutes on the day.

The Tyrone players and management must be delighted to be back in the All-Ireland final given the setback they had earlier in the Ulster championship when they were beaten by Monaghan. They have improved as the championship has progressed. Some players have returned to action after injury while others have simply sharpened up.

It’s such a pity that Dublin are so far ahead of the rest of the counties but I’ve no doubt that Mickey Harte and his team will care little about the odds. If Tyrone could pull off a shock, it would help our game considerably. We all need hope. When Dublin played Tyrone in the Super 8s in Omagh, there wasn’t a huge difference between the teams. Only a goal separated them at the final whistle. Not many teams have pushed Dublin this season but Tyrone did and to a lesser extent, so did Donegal. Dublin have that ability to wear teams down. They are constantly on the move and pass the ball at pace. They are accurate in front of goal but they are vulnerable in defence.

The jury is still out in respect of the Super 8s. It’s a great concept but structurally flawed. Provincial winners’ first game should be at home against a qualifying team. While championship hurling is thriving, football is struggling in terms of excitement and entertainment. It has become tactically stale where lateral passing has become the norm. You have the ball for a while and we’ll have the ball for a while. It’s a mix between rugby league and basketball. Last Sunday’s game was very much like this. Although the game was intriguing and intense, it lacked quality.

I appreciate that there was a lot at stake which would account for some of the nerves on display. All we can do is hope that the GAA comes up with some bright ideas over the winter.

Keeping the faith!

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice