'Does this mean that ultimately the public pays this fine?'

The scene at St Conal's in Letterkenny as captured on social media placeholder image
The scene at St Conal's in Letterkenny as captured on social media | jordanglasgowww

In 2023, patient files and medical records were found poorly stored in a social media clip

Mary T Sweeney, Donegal’s Aontú representative, asks the question of who will be responsible for the files and medical records found in St. Conal’s Hospital, Letterkenny.

Earlier this month, the Data Protection Commission announced its decision to fine the HSE €645,000 following an investigation into the GDPR breach involving abandoned and poorly stored medical files at St. Conal’s Hospital, Letterkenny, and St. Loman's Hospital in Mullingar.

The files were discovered in St. Conal’s Hospital through social media in 2023, when a group of people entered an abandoned building on the campus and shared videos on TikTok showing boxes of old patient records.

“This is simply beyond unacceptable, and the breach of privacy, trust and responsibility is just staggering, and there are so many issues around this that are the cause of deep disquiet.” Mary T Sweeney said. “Is it general medical records from Letterkenny Hospital or Former patients from St Conal’s records, or a combination of both? There appeared to be X-rays among the documents from the video footage shown. The most important point is that private medical files were compromised, regardless of which patient owned them.

“We also have to question why it then took almost three years to investigate this breach of GDPR? This whole debacle throws up a lot of serious questions that need to be answered. Who actually removed the files from Letterkenny General Hospital and brought them over to store in rooms at St Conal’s facility, or were they always stored in St Conal’s?

“Was it HSE staff, or was it a private company in charge of managing these patients’ files? If it was a private company, what was the job description, and were the files to be boxed and secured in a certain way, for example, alphabetically filed, or what instructions were given? How much was the private company paid to move the files?

“As the HSE is funded by the public purse, who really will be left paying the fine? Does this mean that ultimately the public pays this fine? Will the public health service suffer more because the HSE budget is down €625,000?

“Can we get a proportionate breakdown - as to how much each hospital throughout the country on a pro rata basis will be expected to contribute, or lose out on, in next year’s budget allocation in order to pay the fine? What measures have been put in place so this does not happen again?

Crucially, is anybody ever going to be held accountable for this? I have been consistently calling for St. Conal’s to be refurbished and brought back into use. Back in 2019, Confidential medical files and patient lists from Letterkenny University Hospital were also found dumped in a Letterkenny town park and nearby streets. The HSE later confirmed these documents were stolen during a break-in.”

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice