Clonmany Curate's House project finally wins planning approval


Former Curate's House to be transformed into community hub after An Coimisiún Pleanála upholds council decision.
An Coimisiún Pleanála has granted planning permission for the conversion of the former Curate's House in Clonmany into a community hub, despite its own planning inspector recommending that the application be refused.
The decision upholds Donegal County Council's earlier approval for the development by Clonmany Enterprise Development Limited and brings to an end the latest chapter in a long-running planning process surrounding the prominent village building.
Earlier this year, Donegal County Council granted permission for the change of use of the former parish office, which has remained vacant for several years after suffering extensive flood damage caused by a burst pipe. Parish services were subsequently relocated to St Mary's Hall.
The Curate's House was purchased in 2019 by Clonmany Enterprise Development CLG, the organisation behind the annual Clonmany Festival, from the Diocese of Derry.
Under the approved plans, the refurbished building will accommodate four community retail units and a staff canteen on the ground floor, with a committee boardroom, two hot-desk workspaces and a manager's office on the first floor.
An objection to the development was submitted by Pat McGonigle, who questioned both the applicant's legal standing and the lack of detail regarding the proposed retail units.
Mr McGonigle argued that the application failed to clearly identify what type of goods or services would be provided within the proposed "community shops".
Community shops are a “vague term and give no indication as to what type of goods or services will be for sale in these 'shops,” he stated in his submission.
"Most shops serving a small village and surrounding area could reasonably be deemed community shops. I believe it is a reasonable expectation that the planning application for these four proposed shops would clearly indicate what, exactly, are the goods or services that they will be purveying."
He also stated that the application mirrored an earlier proposal which An Coimisiún Pleanála had refused after finding that the applicant had failed to demonstrate sufficient legal interest in the property.
In a detailed assessment for An Coimisiún Pleanála, Planning Inspector Frank O'Donnell concluded that the applicant named on the planning application, "Clonmany Enterprise Development Limited", was not the same legal entity as "Clonmany Enterprise Development Company Limited by Guarantee" listed on the Companies Registration Office website and identified in Land Registry records as the property owner.
Mr O'Donnell recommended that planning permission be refused as the applicant had not demonstrated "sufficient legal estate or interest in the land" nor the approval of the party holding that legal interest.
Despite that recommendation, the Board reached the opposite conclusion. In its decision, An Coimisiún Pleanála said it was satisfied, "that sufficient legal interest has been demonstrated."
The Board also referred to the Department of the Environment's Development Management Guidelines for Planning Authorities, noting that the planning system "is not designed as a mechanism for resolving disputes about title to land or premises or rights over land", adding that such matters are ultimately for the courts.
The Board further pointed to Section 34(13) of the Planning and Development Act, which states that the granting of planning permission does not, in itself, entitle a person to carry out development where they do not otherwise have the legal right to do so.
Planning permission was granted subject to five conditions. Among the conditions, the Board required that the proposed community retail units operate only as shops as defined under the Planning and Development Regulations. Details of the car park layout, signage and lighting must be agreed with Donegal County Council before development begins, while drainage arrangements must comply with the planning authority's requirements.
Opening hours for the retail units have also been restricted to between 8.30am and 8pm Monday to Friday, 8.30am to 6pm on Saturdays, and Midday to 6pm on Sundays, with the premises to remain closed on public and bank holidays unless otherwise agreed with the planning authority.