Residents seek to overturn council approval for 18-metre telecoms mast in their village


Residents raise concerns over visual impact, heritage and lack of assessment of alternative sites
A decision by Donegal County Council to grant planning permission to Eircom Ltd for an 18-metre-high telecommunications mast in the centre of Culdaff has been appealed to An Coimisiún Pleanála.
Local residents Patricia Davenport and Neil McGrory, the latter on behalf of the Culdaff and Cloncha Heritage Group, lodged appeals with the national planning authority earlier this month.
In a detailed appeal, Ms Davenport emphasised that she does not object to the provision of modern telecommunications infrastructure in principle, but rather to the suitability of the proposed site, the lack of assessment of alternatives, including the upgrading or adaptation of an existing mast in the village, and the impact the new mast would have on the visual amenity, heritage and established character of Culdaff.
She asked An Coimisiún to carry out a full, independent review of the application.
Outlining Culdaff's significant early Christian history associated with St Boden, Mr McGrory said the proposed telecommunications mast would be located within an archaeologically sensitive site and would have a negative visual impact on the modern village. He also said the 18-metre-high structure would dominate the skyline and questioned the need for a new mast when the area is already served by good mobile phone coverage and fibre broadband.
Eircom had been granted permission by Donegal County Council in July to install an 18-metre-high steel monopole with three antennas and two dishes, as well as cabinets and other equipment, on the site of the existing Eircom telephone exchange in the village.
In its application, Eircom said the mast would provide essential public infrastructure that would improve broadband connectivity in Culdaff and its hinterland and provide high-quality voice and data services comparable with those available in towns and cities.
The company said there were significant limitations to network coverage in the area, including range and physical obstructions such as buildings and trees, and that the 18-metre-high mast was required to ‘see above’ those obstructions.
It said the new mast would be capable of holding antennas for multiple operators, which would prevent the proliferation of other masts in the future. The existing masts, Eircom said, are too far away or already at capacity to support fourth- and fifth-generation mobile telecommunication networks, which allow people to use data-intensive applications such as social media, internet browsing and downloading files.
It also noted a planning precedent at Fahan, where it sought and obtained permission for a similar 18-metre mast from the then An Bord Pleanála after initially being refused by Donegal County Council.
An Coimisiún Pleanála will examine the application and the objections. It has not provided a timeline for when it expects to issue its final ruling.