The Alternative View: Is training burnout an issue for Donegal after Croke Park exit?

Michael Murphy kicking a free on Sundayplaceholder image
Michael Murphy kicking a free on Sunday | SPORTSFILE

In The Alternative View this week we look at Donegal’s failure to make the last eight with just one win in four championship matches.

It wasn’t supposed to be like this. At the end of March Donegal were rivalling Kerry as favourites to take Sam but, apart from a brief resurgence in Killarney, the road has been narrowing for Donegal ever since then.

Winning a second ever National League title left Donegal on a high, especially in the manner it was achieved, with attractive attacking football.

The momentum achieved during the league quickly disappeared but we all thought the defeat at home to Down in O’Donnell Park in the opening game in the Ulster championship was just a blip and one that might be good for Donegal in the long run.

As it turned out we may have been off the mark in that respect. Granted the win against Kerry in Killarney was a bright spot, but it did come with a health warning as Kerry were reduced to 14 men and seemed to throw in the towel in the second half.

Donegal are not the only team looking for answers this week as Armagh are also gone from the scene before the quarter-finals have been reached. Who would have predicted that?

Of the eight teams left, four of them will be playing in Division 2 of the League next year which proves that there is a huge gulf between league and championship.

Donegal’s cup may have been overflowing in March, but since then the form of many of the players has taken a dip and it is vital that answers are found as to why this has happened.

Michael Murphy played his 200th game for Donegal and stood up to kick a magnificent free under pressure to take his side to extra-time on Sunday, running the gauntlet of many Dublin players, not least Ciaran Kilkenny. The writing was beginning to appear on the wall with Dublin dominating in many areas, especially from kick-outs. And but for some poor shooting, the Dubs should really have won the game in normal time.

Will we see Michael Murphy next year? It would be great for Donegal but surely if he is to play in 2017 - 20 years after his first game - he should not be used in the league and just be ready for championship. The media has been on his back since the incident in the National League final and it has been noticeable in recent games that he is getting more involved. Even on Sunday after kicking that critical two point free to send the game to extra-time he should have been smiling at the Dublin players who were obviously giving him plenty of trash talk.

Because he has been in the limelight since the league final, being booed in Killarney and again on Sunday, getting involved just gave the referee the opportunity to penalise him.

Even if his temperament was strained on Sunday, his commitment to the cause never waned, even getting back to make a magnificent block late in the game in front of the Donegal posts. He always wears the Donegal jersey with pride.

And then there is the social media side of things. I don’t look at social media but I’ve been told that the Glenswilly man has been vilified by the so-called keyboard warriors but that seems to be the world we live in nowadays.

Donegal have to go away and lick their wounds and there may have to be a root and branch look at how we coach the game under the new rules.

And the game that we once knew has changed, changed utterly.

The Donegal blueprint since Jim McGuinness’s return - and not just with the county senior team but with every team from U-14 upwards - is based on a game of possession and not taking many chances.

Remember the All-Ireland semi-final of 2011, Donegal’s first introduction to the big time under McGuinness, was won by a margin of 0-8 to 0-6 (and we were lucky to get 14 points).

The arrival of the new rules and the three up, four back means that keeping the scoreboard moving is paramount. And long may that continue. The game is a much better spectacle as a result, even if there could be a few tweaks here and there.

Michael Murphy had a huge input into how the game has developed under those new rules as he was part of the initial committee before making the decision to return to play.

Donegal’s blueprint of moving the ball almost all the time by hand creates two big difficulties. It is slower than kicking the ball and it wastes an enormous amount of energy over a 70 minute game under the summer sun.

Even when Donegal do get the ball as far as the opposition 45m line, the energy levels to create a score doesn’t seem to be always there and that results in the ball being transferred over and back - something that was the main reason for changing to the new rules in the first place.

It was noticeable in the respective warm-ups on Sunday in Croke Park with Donegal’s more hand-passing based while Dublin’s had more kicking, especially longer kick-passing.

The Donegal coaching manual may have to be re-written from U-14 upwards so that individual talent is not curtailed in the midst of this possession-first game. Players must be given the latitude to go for scores and that shooting is not just for a privileged few. Getting players to go for long-range points is vital for the present game.

Donegal didn’t get one two point effort against Cork and their first on Sunday came from an unlikely source, Shane O’Donnell, but the St Eunan’s man went for it because Donegal were playing with an advantage. He would never have attempted it under normal circumstances. This is an area that has to be worked on. It just can’t be left to these so called ‘shooters’ any more.

Given the lack of energy in the last couple of games against Dublin and especially against Cork, some analysis of the Donegal training methods have to be looked at. Did Donegal peak too soon in 2026? How much heavy training was done during the early months of the year?

We are not privy to that sort of information and indeed, if we were, very few of us would be able to analyse it anyway. But there has to be questions asked, even if answers are not to be found.

There was some really great analysis by Kieran Cunningham on the Brendan Devenney’S Highland Radio show on Monday night with the Glencolmcille man feeling there was a need for a fresh voice at management level for Donegal.

Cunningham made particular reference also to the fact that a number of experienced players walked away at the end of last year which he felt left the back-up in recent weeks falling on very young shoulders.

In Jim McGuinness’s first term the first two years were very successful, winning Ulster titles, while there was a drop-off in the third year.

Is history repeating itself in the second term?

And could we see a fresh Donegal in 2027, just as we did in the fourth year of the first term when they won back Ulster and reached the All-Ireland final in 2014?

We are always willing to dream.

MATCH FACTS

Scorers for Dublin: Con O’Callaghan 1-5,1tp; Colm Basquel 0-7,1tp,1f; Paddy Small 1-2; Seán Guiden 0-4,1tp; Cormac Costello 0-2,1f; Ross McGarry 0-2; Brian Howard, Ciarán Kilkenny, Lee Gannon and Peadar Ó Cofaigh Byrne 0-1 each.

Scorers for Donegal: Peadar Mogan 1-1; Michael Langan 0-4; Michael Murphy 0-4,1tpf,1f; Shea Malone 1-0; Jason McGee 0-3,1tp; Ryan McHugh 0-3; Shane O’Donnell 0-2,tp; Gavin Mulreany 0-2,tpf; Eoghan ‘Bán’ Gallagher, Conor O’Donnell, Finnbarr Roarty 0-1 each

Dublin: Evan Comerford; Lee Gannon, Nathan Doran, David Byrne; Seán McMahon, Charlie McMorrow, Peadar Ó Cofaigh Byrne; Theo Clancy, Brian Howard, Colm Basquel, Con O'Callaghan, Niall Scully; Paddy Small, Ciarán Kilkenny, Cormac Costello. Subs: Eoghan Kennedy for Doran (29), Ross McGarry for Costello (54), Seán Guiden for Small (67), Seán Bugler for Gannon (75), Tim Deering for O’Callaghan (78), Josh Bannon for MacMahon (85)

Donegal: Gavin Mulreany; Eoghan Ban Gallagher, Brendan McCole, Peadar Mogan; Max Campbell, Caolan McGonagle, Finnbarr Roarty; Jason McGee, Hugh McFadden; Shane O’Donnell, Michael Langan, Ciaran Moore; Conor O’Donnell, Michael Murphy, Shea Malone. Subs: Oisín Gallen and Ryan McHugh for Malone and Campbell (ht), Ciarán Thompson for C O’Donnell (63), Seán Martin for McFadden (65); Dáire Ó Baoill, C O’Donnell and Campbell for Martin, Thompson and Roarty (et), Shea Malone and Roarty for C O’Donnell and Moore (ht/et), Thompson for Gallen (77).

Referee: Martin McNally (Monaghan)

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice